I’ve never gone shroom hunting myself even though a few of them are easily recognizable. I believe chicken of the woods has no lookalikes so I’d probably take some of those in the wild, but I also know there are morel, chantarelles and indigo milkcaps all have lookalikes that can melt your liver and rot your brain assuming you even survive.
I took a number of wild foraging classes with the Dean of Green at Eat the Weeds and he had a quick little aside for amateurs who want to mushroom hunt. He said, “Mycology is a self-regulating profession.” In other words, if you’re careless or get it wrong, you’re dead. So he never forages for mushrooms, just greens, tubers, fruits, lichens, etc…. It’s much safer as there are very few deadly poisonous plants and a ton of deadly poisonous mushrooms.
I have had a lot of unusual mushrooms due to grow your own mushroom kits, an Asian store that Carries A ton of dried and fresh mushrooms that mainstream white grocery stores do not carry and a farmer’s market booth with a professional mycologist who does forage local morels, pecan truffles and other wild mushrooms. And my opinion is that chicken of the woods is just…kinda meh.
My favorites are Eringi or “King Oyster Mushroom“ which had a firm flesh unlike most oyster mushrooms, are very large and easy to utilize (typically one Is the size of a zucchini). It’s got a great, sweet seafood flavor more like scallop or perfectly cooked octopus than “oysters”.
I’m also a huge fan of black trumpet mushrooms, they have a sweet blue cheese funk to them. They work FANTASTIC as a mushroom gravy for steaks especially long dry Aged beef that has a blue cheese funk anyways.
But the mushroom I buy the most is either the brown or white beech mushroom also called shimeji because our Asian market sells them so cheaply (literally $2 for a big quart container filled with them) and they stay plump and not rotten in the fridge for weeks. They have a slightly bitter flavor various Asian cultures actually appreciate when raw but when cooked they lose the bitterness and just taste faintly of cashews regardless of color. They’re also harvested little, about the size of a pinky finger so they’re basically already perfect eating size when cut from the “roots” and look great in soups and stir fries. I use them in almost every Thai curry I make regardless of what type of curry or what else is in it. Don’t confuse them with the even smaller and leggier enoki which I find too bland to be worth messing with.
And I do like Morels and pecan truffles when at restaurants or a trusted mycologist has picked them, but I would never hunt them myself and as a result they are pricy. I’ve grown various colored oyster mushrooms and lion mane mushrooms at home and they’re good as well and you can take pride in growing them yourself but I prefer the other three plus morels and pecan truffles that I mentioned above. I seldom use generic Pennyslvania white mushrooms or portobellos/criminis as they’re too bland for me to normally mess with but I had a striking revelation recently about three weeks ago. I went to a low country boil recently in Tallahassee and in addition to the usual shrimp, sausage, potatoes, onion and corn they added a bunch of white and baby Bella’s/criminis to the boil. And they were wonderful, completely soaking up the flavorful “broth”/”brine” of the boil and all that goodness the sausage and shrimp leaked out. They were better than the shrimp! So I might need to reevaluate using them, at least when I do my own low country shrimp or crawfish boil.
As far as hen of the woods, as I mentioned they are a perfectly fine…even average mushroom, but I don’t buy it that often (I do see it all the time in the woods and even shady spots downtown in Tallahassee) Because the flavor doesn’t equal the price imo. But when I do get them I season them similar to bland chicken breast so I put a fine sprinkle of Spice Island yellow Curry Powder, some Badia poultry seasoning and a little Cavender’s seasoning and then sauté them in garlic butter. They turn out relatively “chickeny” when handled that way and taste great over rice especially a Cuban yellow rice Or a long grain mixed with wild rice.