Perryhawk, I respect you but Fran is a lost cause. His calling the referees cheats ended his tenure here as referees will have long memories and willmake Iowa pay as long as Fran is here, much like Tom Davis could not see any Chicago inner city kids after the Jim Collins/ Bruce Pearl Deon Thomas Chevy Blazer incident.
Tyler is not coming back and this program's athletic talent is fairly weak. PMac is not going to make the difference like Weiskamp did this season. Iowa needs to land several top 100 kids in the next class at PG, PF and C. Joe and CJ Fredrick can man the 2 position well enough for Iowa's future. Nunge and Garza has at least two years left in the program but Iowa needs new depth. Pemsl without a 20' jump shot is not a starter. Iowa needs at least one 6'+ PG who can actually dribble drive and shoot.
Iowa needs to land Xavier Foster and a PG like Tyler Beard or Caleb Love (or both or one and Nijel Pack) and a big man like Dain Dainja.
So, going in reverse order on the points in your post (and I think this is good discussion-no disrespect either way-just a difference of opinion).
I would love to have everyone of the recruits you mentioned in your last sentence...The video I've watched on the Beard kid really impresses me....athletic, smart, and he likes to play defense. He would be a great recruit. I think we're hosed on Dainja based on what I've read, but I really don't have an inside info on these recruits.
You stated that Pmac is not going to make the difference that Joe W did this season...I agree 100%, but probably for different reasons. First and foremost Joe W is outstanding...and he started and played a vital role in the turnaround from last season. Patrick won't be needed at that level and probably isn't physically ready to do that yet...I am guessing he does play a back up role off of the bench and that he is a pretty good player...a very good player long term.
Again, I am all about the recruiting...2020 class is of vital importance. I am really discouraged by the information provided by HR on recruiting....I am a paid member and bball recruiting information has dropped considerable in the time I have been a member.
Last but not least, where we have the biggest difference of opinion, is about Fran and him being done here. I don't believe that is the case.....I have been pretty critical of officiating, but I don't believe that "officials" as a group are going to be out to get Fran and inflict constant punishment on Iowa due to his actions. I DON'T approve of Frans actions...to me that was the biggest mistake and misjudgement on his part of this entire last season.
All that said, he has proven to be a pretty good coach, we bring back a pretty good team, and the athleticism is adequate....not great, but like Wisconsn teams of the past we are good enough to win at a high level. Hopefully the recruiting for 2020 upgrades the level of athleticism.
Good discussion....and we will see how our thoughts/beliefs play out over the next year.