ADVERTISEMENT

Has the Iowa brand lost its luster?

I personally think the new facility being finished and an uptick in the HWC can turn things around.

I personally think recruits put more emphasis on winning over facilities. I'd put a lot of money on that.

Link to uptick in the HWC? I see no uptick.

There's Spencer Lee and that's about it. I love the other guys, but they are not on the level needed.

Who knows what Lee's future even looks like.
 
The state of Iowa kind of fell off around the same time that Karl went to PA, Karl is a legend yes but that compounded with Iowa having a dark period of elite prospects has a lot to do with it. Then Iowa finally opened up the PA pipeline, and only one became a champ. Is what it is. If we don't have 3/4 new individual champs within the next 5 years I would be calling for a change.
 
Sorry, but the best of the best would rather be in Rec Hall at the moment.

And "at the moment" has been going on for a decade.

It's going to take a HUGE change to get back on top and hold it.

Different coaching blood would be a good start. I don't really see other options.
The trouble is it's hard to replace a coach with success to beat a coach with much greater success. Sanderson is in a similar position that Gable had in his heyday. It's impossible to just be better than arguably the best. when Gable was coaching I just hoped for PSU success as much as possible. If you get into replacing every coach who isn't winning like Gable you foster program instability.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MSU158 and Hawk_82
We're doing pretty good for not having individual or team titles. I don't care THAT much about the new facilities, UFC sponsorship, attendance records, sold out season tickets, most watched duals, etc although all that stuff is pretty cool. I would trade all that for the occasional team and individual titles.

Recruits would say the exact same thing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: goldenanimal
The trouble is it's hard to replace a coach with success to beat a coach with much greater success. Sanderson is in a similar position that Gable had in his heyday. It's impossible to just be better than arguably the best. when Gable was coaching I just hoped for PSU success as much as possible. If you get into replacing every coach who isn't winning like Gable you foster program instability.
I agree it's not easy.

Keep a Brands and replace the other.

Terrible to say I know.

Different assistants wouldn't hurt my feelings either.

Why is our coaching staff 100% Iowa Hawkeye???
 
  • Like
Reactions: bourbon n blues
I personally think recruits put more emphasis on winning over facilities. I'd put a lot of money on that.

Link to uptick in the HWC? I see no uptick.

There's Spencer Lee and that's about it. I love the other guys, but they are not on the level needed.

Who knows what Lee's future even looks like.
I never said a new facility means more to assembling a team compared to recruiting. Those are your words. As for recruits, we just had the #1 recruiting class by some media's rankings and a top 3 class by all media this year.

As for the uptick in the HWC, you must not follow the sport much. Compare the HWC this year to the last 4 years. We actually have guys wrestling. These are domestic rankings
57kg Spencer Lee #5
61kg Desanto #3
65kg Lugo #8
70kg Eierman #10
79kg Marinelli #7
97kg Kueter #9
125kg Cass #8
I expect to see even more involvement next year hopefully with a healthy Spencer Lee, Warner, Assad, Brands, Schriver, and Woods.
Future: Arnold, Ayala, Ferrari's, Kennedy,Block, Caliendo, Hill, Petersen, ect....

I would love to see M* or Terry on the U15/U17 world coaching staff to start developing relationships with these young guys.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon_4lz6x5o7izepf
No, you don't just keep plugging away, you have to identify your weaknesses and make changes to improve. Just plugging away while others have changed is not the way to go.
I get the sentiment, but what if it's impossible at the current time and your staff for example is the second best? Iowa had arguably the best coach ever, at least best at that time in Gable. They developed a culture of if you want to win, you come here.

Obviously much was Gable related and until Sanderson rose to prominence Iowa was probably the top program post Gable to 2010.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hawk_82
I agree it's not easy.

Keep a Brands and replace the other.

Terrible to say I know.

Different assistants wouldn't hurt my feelings either.

Why is our coaching staff 100% Iowa Hawkeye???
I agree with this. Move Terry and Telford to the HWC and add 2 new coaches to the college staff. I'd love to see a couple new guys added to the HWC roster. Nolf, Gable, and Cox would be at the top of my list.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sett1997 and el dub
I agree it's not easy.

Keep a Brands and replace the other.

Terrible to say I know.

Different assistants wouldn't hurt my feelings either.

Why is our coaching staff 100% Iowa Hawkeye???
Loyalty, it's a great thing but it has drawbacks. It can get muddled or incestuous in some ways with everyone thinking the same way. PSU football struggled with that in the later Paterno years ( regular football stuff, not scandal stuff).

To me it's the problem with great success, you have to be cautious about making radical changes. A lessor program can gamble easier than the top dogs. Think the Oakland A's and moneyball, they needed to do it to win. the Red Sox then adopted that approach and had the money to make it work. Once the big boys get the new idea down, it's hard to beat them.
 
Tom Brands (and Terry) have earned the right to decide when they are done coaching wrestling at The University of Iowa. What they have done for our program as Iowa wrestlers, on the World and Olympic level and their time here as coaches cannot be overlooked. They are Iowa Wrestling.
 
This board is ALL about beating this subject to death. Some people think the more outraged they are on a message board, the more things are likely to change.
Really bad take Spooner. This is legit question for message board. Bringing it up is not outrage nor does it mean that the poster thinks bringing it up will solve the problem. Nebraska football fans were in denial for a long time. I see "give it more time". It shouldn't take that long, and nothing seems to be changing. A new facility will do nothing but allow the Athletic department to assign more costs to wrestling. Is it going to make our wrestlers better? Not really. Sure more space and newer space will help a little, but won't cure what ills us. They have access to weights, trainers, and coaches and the room right now. We are behind PSU on recruiting, wrestler development, training methods, and wrestling skills. Everything that the coach is responsible for. Its not going to magically happen. Yes, we won title a couple years ago, but we are a far inferior program and its getting to be a bigger gap. I have no doubt that if we were to hire Cael Sanderson, that we'd be the top program again within just a couple years regardless of new facilities or whatever.
 
Tom Brands (and Terry) have earned the right to decide when they are done coaching wrestling at The University of Iowa. What they have done for our program as Iowa wrestlers, on the World and Olympic level and their time here as coaches cannot be overlooked. They are Iowa Wrestling.

The same has been said for other head coaches in different sports.

They end up staying too long and the program suffers.

It's a difficult discussion.
 
Tom Brands (and Terry) have earned the right to decide when they are done coaching wrestling at The University of Iowa. What they have done for our program as Iowa wrestlers, on the World and Olympic level and their time here as coaches cannot be overlooked. They are Iowa Wrestling.
I'm a bit confused. Are you saying one of the reasons they deserve to coach Iowa is that they've done wonders with our Iowa wrestlers at the World and Olympic level? Or are you saying that because they are World and Olympic medalists themselves they deserve to coach Iowa? Because I would contend they haven't done that much with Iowa wrestlers at the World and Olympic level and that personal wrestling accomplishments by them are incredible, but in no way does that mean they should be coaches at Iowa forever.
 
I'm a bit confused. Are you saying one of the reasons they deserve to coach Iowa is that they've done wonders with our Iowa wrestlers at the World and Olympic level? Or are you saying that because they are World and Olympic medalists themselves they deserve to coach Iowa? Because I would contend they haven't done that much with Iowa wrestlers at the World and Olympic level and that personal wrestling accomplishments by them are incredible, but in no way does that mean they should be coaches at Iowa forever.
I don't try to explain things to confused people.
It was pretty self-explanatory.
 
Tom Brands (and Terry) have earned the right to decide when they are done coaching wrestling at The University of Iowa.
Nah, they aren't above being let go if they don't deliver. I bet the Brands would say the same thing. Nobody should get a pass or guaranteed job until they wish to leave. Not at that job anyways.
 
When they feel they are no longer delivering they will step away. As of now that is not an issue.
You can't just plug in new people and create a dynasty, they don't happen very often. After Gable left Iowa won 6 titles, Oklahoma State won 4, Minnesota 3 until Sanderson took PSU on their current run. If you add in Big Ten titles, Big Ten individual winners, and placing since then you can make the case they are the most successful team from post Gable to now.

If you want to quibble and say what about PSU, ok, who is better than Iowa other than them over that time period? If they want to argue 2010 to now ask the same question. Some it comes down to Iowa isn't the current dynasty but they're arguably the next best in the rest which is why I say keep plugging away. It's not easy to replicate dynasties.
 
It is really pretty simple. Ours guys don't get better in our room.

Now, there are different reasons for this and everyone will have an opinion. Here's mine. We don't have the coaches and guys in the HWC anymore that are the best around. Until that changes, we are who we are. Wrestlers get better by wrestling guys that are better than them, it's not debatable.
 
They need to recruit better. Period. Too many top 20/30/40 guys.
In order to recruit better they need to show they can win. Chicken or egg, who the f knows. Currently we don’t have either. We had a pretty nice chicken last year. But Iowa can’t have nice things so we tore his knees out for the third time and decided that this year we were gonna focus on sports cars.

Am I mixing metaphors? Probably, but then again there’s only so many times we can say the same thing over and over.

Now it appears that Iowa is “gambling” with their future and it seems that a “Big T”ime producer is gonna be riding pine so Iowa throws over a mill at a gold medal but that gold medal Oliver Twisted us and said more please.Iowa is left holding the bag while striking out on the three transfers they really wanted. They did get a few people just not people at our two black hole weights cough 133 cough 197.

TLDR version: Iowa seems to be too often caught on the back foot and reacting, instead of being proactive. This is for everything: recruiting; (you have Tom or Terry be the first to contact one the best light weight prospects in the county not 6”7 happy bob telford. This shit isn’t rocket science). Development; not seeing a lot of success here…other than Nelson last year. But ya can’t tell me Big T has gotten better or Assad has. When recruiting and development suffer we finish 3rd, land a few big time transfers at need weights and occasionally we get first. If and when gambling and injuries are thrown into the mix. Who the hell knows where we finish.
 
It is really pretty simple. Ours guys don't get better in our room.

Now, there are different reasons for this and everyone will have an opinion. Here's mine. We don't have the coaches and guys in the HWC anymore that are the best around. Until that changes, we are who we are. Wrestlers get better by wrestling guys that are better than them, it's not debatable.

I think when guys come in they get much better at a quick pace. In the first 12 months guys develop a lot, a little in the second 12 months——and then pretty much stagnant with often some decline as their bodies suffer from the intensity, after that. Double edge sword as the intensity brings those early gains. Almost never do guys develop more attacks, get better scrambling, pick up from their teammates, etc.

If we are doing something to address this it definitely isn’t working.
 
BTW, I am in the camp that Iowa needs to hire a great, middle weight technician like Dake. Just mauling and brawling only takes you so far.
Spot on, you can see PSU wrestlers actually change their game plans match to match with opponents. I think their strategizing is on a whole other level.
Watch RBY matches with Desanto in sequence, Kem vs Starfish, and Kerk vs Cass.
Just a few examples.
 
Last edited:
Spot on, you can see PSU wrestlers actually change their game plans match to match with opponents. I think their straegizing is on a whole other level.
Watch RBY matches with Desanto in sequence. Also Kerk VS Cass.
Just a couple of examples.
I might be in the minority but I think their wrestlers have the talent to go another level. It's the level of recruit that is the problem.

The recruiting rankings show this. It's top 10 pfp that are winning titles for them. It's not even top 10. It's top 3 p4p.

I also think them getting the top p4p guys at upper weights, where most of the competition plays college football is another factor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trapper85
I also think them getting the top p4p guys at upper weights, where most of the competition plays college football is another factor.
True statement here. Over the years far more team points have came from 157 and up.
I’d like to see more set ups from close space, meaning you could go heavy hands if need be. More ducks, short drags, slide buys and high crotch to create angles. The best take downs are always finished quickly. Which has always been true know matter what era you’re discussing.
I have no clue how to coach scramble positions, however, I seem to hold my breath when we’re in those positions. Unless it was Kem Dawg.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Fan In Black
What exactly do they offer spiritual wise?
They offer a solid foundation in spirituality. A belief system if you will.
I am not going to get into a debate about Christianity. However, I will say it’s faith based. I think it offers a base for staying emotionally stable, it helps to smooth out highs and lows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sett1997
I personally think the new facility being finished and an uptick in the HWC can turn things around. I would wager Arnold and the Ferrari's will lead us to a national title.
While i agree with your post that the new facility will be a nice recruiting tool, I will wait and see what Arnold and Ferrari do at the next level... And, what do you mean by an uptick in the HWC? How does that uptick occur and define what or how an uptick occurs. Currently the HWC does not have a single member on the US National Team What happens with HWC is up to Tom and the staff (including Daniel Dennis). Will they get viable senior level guys to train there (and in turn work with Iowa wrestlers), or will HWC continue to be a place for recently graduated Iowa wrestlers to stay in town and get paid to workout with the current college wrestlers?
 
Christ, some of you guys need to get a life. This message board has gone way down hill. It's sad really...
 
Credit Carl and his crew. They bought their first few National Championships but have since created a winning culture. How do you beat them? Well you have to spend money, adapt your style a bit and take a risk on something. All of those things are being done guys. It will take a little more time but the Hawks are coming and coming hard. We won’t get all the top end recruits but our piece of the pie will definitely get bigger over the next couple of years. I am looking forward to the next 4 or 5 years guys it’s going to start changing soon. I have faith and that’s all I need.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pakman770
I agree it's not easy.

Keep a Brands and replace the other.

Terrible to say I know.

Different assistants wouldn't hurt my feelings either.

Why is our coaching staff 100% Iowa Hawkeye???
Don't think it really matters whether the coaching staff is 100% Hawks or any other program. What matters is whether they bring the skills necessary to improve/win in today's wrestling 'environment'. But I agree in this case that some shake-up might not hurt, though even that depends on finding a willing/better alternative. Not always as easy as it sounds.
 
  • Like
Reactions: el dub
I personally think the new facility being finished and an uptick in the HWC can turn things around. I would wager Arnold and the Ferrari's will lead us to a national title.
Cael is better than the brands.

The brands are fine coaches who can win a title every now and then, but as long as cael is around they will not dominate.
 
Last edited:
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT