Yep. That year:
Keegan:
7.2 PPG
0.5 APG
0.6 TOPG
0.83 AST/TO ratio
5.1 RPG
Connor:
3.3 PPG
3.6 APG
1.0 TOPG
3.6:1 AST/TO ratio
3.1 RPG
So Keegan, w/ 0.5 APG was worth about 8.2 PPG
Connor w/ 3.6 AGP was worth about 10.5 PPG
Keegan averaged 18 min/game; Connor 23 min/game
Pretty even, I'd say; and the extra assists and better AST/TO ratio, you'd probably start Connor over Keegan that year.
Keegan made a HUGE jump the following year. Connor regressed that year; but bounced back to put up slightly better numbers the year after when Keegan entered the draft.
Keegan had much higher upside, but in his Freshman year, he most assuredly was neither a "star", nor a future NBA draft pick.