You could say that about a LOT of coaches. I mean is Kim Mulkey a "great coach" or a great recruiter? She had both Naylissa Smith at Baylor and Angel Reese at LSU. Both good athletes who have VERY limited skill sets. How much did they get, "coached up"?
I'd have to agree mostly about Sides. The biggest issue is the roster. Just too much dead weight on the bench to compete with the top teams. Thats not on the HC.
I've also made the same comment about college football. Was Meyer a great coach at OSU, or Day? How hard can it be to recruit there? And frankly when you have basically an NFL roster loaded with high 4 stars and 5 star players, how do you not beat pretty much every one you play? Great coaching, or just better resources?