ADVERTISEMENT

VOTE: Is Kirk Ferentz a Hall of Famer? Assume he gets to a 60.00 Win% & stays there (currently @ 59.83%). Needs to go 9-4 next yr to get to 60.16%

Is Kirk Ferentz a Hall of Famer?

  • I am an Iowa fan. YES!

  • I am not an Iowa fan. YES!

  • I am an Iowa fan. NO!

  • I am not an Iowa fan. NO!


Results are only viewable after voting.
My guess would be if he starts 3-0 he goes. But then if he goes 4-1 after the Indiana game and if that would push him over, I didn't calculate, he would also retire. Why not? A lot of you want him gone so this would be great timing by him.....
 
He needs at least a 9-4 record with this schedule + 1 postseason game:

Aug. 30 — vs. Albany

Sept. 6 — at Iowa State

Sept. 13 — vs. UMass

Sept. 20 — at Rutgers

Sept. 27 — vs. Indiana

Oct. 4 — Bye

Oct. 11 — at Wisconsin

Oct. 18 — vs. Penn State

Oct. 25 — vs. Minnesota

Nov. 1 — Bye

Nov. 8 — vs. Oregon

Nov. 15 — at USC

Nov. 22 — vs. Michigan State

Nov. 28 — at Nebraska

If he can go 9-4 with that schedule he should be in the HOF and retire. Thing is, we played exactly 1 of the big 5 conference teams and still only finished 8-5. Next year we play 3 of them, plus at Iowa St, at Wisconsin, and at Nebraska.

I think if we go 6-6 Kirk will be happy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: spiderland
Yes. His consistency and quality of teams of the past 25 years is impressive.

-Coaching a runner-up Heisman
-beating the defending national champions coached by Nick Saban
-has won two B1G titles
-teams that crack the top 10 at the end of the season with No. 8 in 2002, 2003, and 2004, No. 7 in 2009, No. 9 in 2015
-multiple coach of the year awards (AP, Eddie Robinson, Walter Camp)
-and the sheer amount of talent that has been sent to the NFL, despite being a program that is not a blue blood.

Despite having issues with nepotism and sticking to an archaic offensive scheme, Kirk is a class act that I'm proud to have as a coach. Keep in mind that Hayden Fry did not meet the 60% requirement, but is still in the HOF.
No just No take off the Iowa glasses. Where are his championships. Longevity for wins doesn't make you HOF. When was his last win against a ranked team?
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 2D_ and spiderland
Kirk benefited from Gary's ineptitude for many years. And all the years in the Big Ten West. That's why he's able to sneak up the win ladder - it's that simple. I voted Iowa Fan / No.
 
I think if we go 6-6 Kirk will be happy.
Happy? I’d be frickin’ ecstatic. You realize how much would have to go right to pull off 6 wins? We only managed 8 wins against one of the easiest schedules in all of the B1G (I think most services had their schedule ranked #15 in B1G). Next season the team will be worse and the schedule might be the toughest in the B1G. Iowa would have to have most of their opponents playing like Alabama in the 1st quarter of their bowl game today.
 
Happy? I’d be frickin’ ecstatic. You realize how much would have to go right to pull off 6 wins? We only managed 8 wins against one of the easiest schedules in all of the B1G (I think most services had their schedule ranked #15 in B1G). Next season the team will be worse and the schedule might be the toughest in the B1G. Iowa would have to have most of their opponents playing like Alabama in the 1st quarter of their bowl game today.

I’m well aware of how soft the schedule was. I’m not sure it could have been more favorable for us. I expect our future annual schedules to be closer to next years than this year.
 
Happy? I’d be frickin’ ecstatic. You realize how much would have to go right to pull off 6 wins? We only managed 8 wins against one of the easiest schedules in all of the B1G (I think most services had their schedule ranked #15 in B1G). Next season the team will be worse and the schedule might be the toughest in the B1G. Iowa would have to have most of their opponents playing like Alabama in the 1st quarter of their bowl game today.
Did you jump on Alabama's site and demand they fire that worthless coach for only 10 wins? Maybe 9, too lazy to look it up!
 
I’m thinking many respondents here care more about the aesthetics of this poll/question than Kirk does. How many here HONESTLY believe that Kirk signed on here in 1999 thinking he might become the “winningest” football coach in B10 history?

Fans are fanatics, there is no doubt. Clear vision is often clouded by opinions. Many Opinions by folks who are really not qualified make a sound judgment. If I had a vote, I would vote “Hell, yes!” But I don’t have a vote…….just memories of Iowa football from Evy, to Burns, to Nagel, to Lauterbur, to Commings, to Fry and to Kirk. Kirk haas won a lot of football games….and a football coach’s job is to………WIN football games.
 
Update after Iowa's 27-24 loss to Missouri in the Music City Bowl:

You can change your vote, if needed.

As we have been discussing in this thread since September 2023, one of the stipulations for the College Football Hall of Fame is you have to have won 60% of your games.

Assuming Kirk gets to 60% next season (which he currently is just below) and stays there, what say you?

Kirk has now been the head coach in 361 games. He's won 59.83% of those games.

To be at 60.00% (or better) at the end of the 2025 season, assuming a 13 game season, Kirk needs to go 9-4 (or better), which would put him at 225-149 (60.16%).

Kirk's current record:

.......12-21 (36.4%):...............3 years at Maine..........(1990-92)
204
-124 (62.2%):...........26 seasons at Iowa (1999-present)
..................................................................
216-145 (59.83%) Overall Record
========================


When Kirk hit win #200 he became the 24th Division I coach to reach that milestone.

Keep in mind that KF never had a 60% season until his 7th year as a head coach when Iowa went 11-2 in 2002.

Kirk's first 6 years as a head coach:

12-21 (36.4%.......3 years at Maine)
...1-10 (9.1%...........Year 1 at IOWA)
...3-9 (25.0%.......Year 2 at IOWA)
....7-5 (58.3%.......Year 3 at IOWA)
.........................................................................
23-45 (33.8%) Record
===========================

Regarding the Aug 31, 2024 season opener vs Illinois State (40-0 Iowa win):


Longevity gets him in … that is all
 
Probably due to the number of men he has put into the NFL. On wins, he hasn't beaten the bluebloods enough to make a statement on his tenure.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT