ADVERTISEMENT

CKLV

165- McFadden, Va Tech via Depaul HS, PINS Wick
Frank the Tank in the corner
Here's some reason for optimism. Marinelli handled McFadden in freestyle recently. McFadden wins the Cliff Keen. Sure, different styles and all, but folk is Alex's strength. You gotta like that.
 
Not even a good troll.
Here we go again. You moved back to Ia I'm moving back to Scottsdale, but I still grew up with Gable and not a troll. I picked Nickal at the beginning of last year and you called me a troll for PSU. How about I know something about wrestling?
 
How did the redshirt work out for Marinelli? Still hasn't seen the mat as a starter because he is hurt. You never know what will happen in the future. The point is I hate the argument that we will be better in the future by redshirting. I agree if Spencer isn't cleared by the medical staff and he doesn't want to go then redshirt him. Warner is healthy. Beat the #2 guy and is better than Wilcke. Give this team some excitement and maybe it will rub off on the other guys.
And if he and his family prefer he red shirt? If anytyhing knowing that two wrestlers like Warner and Lee will be there for the next 4 years will help with recruiting.
 
Officiating is so different from official to official it's ridiculous. College wrestling shouldn't battle problems like this with bad refs. Get these guys on the same page...
 
  • Like
Reactions: NYWRESTLER94
Here we go again. You moved back to Ia I'm moving back to Scottsdale, but I still grew up with Gable and not a troll. I picked Nickal at the beginning of last year and you called me a troll for PSU. How about I know something about wrestling?

Oliver looked great at Midlands too...until Sorensen beat him in the finals. At NCAAs, Oliver was majored by Chisko who was majored by Brandon. Against anybody not named Zain, Sorensen has pretty much been money for the past two years. A few losses here and there but nothing he hasn't paid back at the end of the season.
 
Oliver looked great at Midlands too...until Sorensen beat him in the finals. At NCAAs, Oliver was majored by Chisko who was majored by Brandon. Against anybody not named Zain, Sorensen has pretty much been money for the past two years. A few losses here and there but nothing he hasn't paid back at the end of the season.
Hope you're right
 
Know it is early but watching the CLV Ohio State looks tough.
Penn State best bet is to pull the shirt on N. Lee. I don't think
they can afford to not get few points this year from 125 to 141.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chickenman Testa
We're a month into the season. I suspect Marinelli's redshirt year helped him a whole lot, as a matter of fact. I don't think you're really proving anything by bringing him up, as I expect him to wrestle this year when it counts, and I think he'll do very well. Sure, we can't predict the future. Marinelli could have wrestled last year and blown out his knee as a true freshman. That wouldn't have been good, either. We can second-guess and talk about hypotheticals until we're blue in the face. That's a pretty pointless endeavor.

I think you're arguing mostly with a straw man. I understand that you're frustrated that Lee and Warner aren't out there in varsity competition tearing it up, but let's be reasonable -- burning Warner's redshirt at this point would be pretty silly. Don't you think it was exciting for his teammates and fans to see him major #3 senior 2x AA Miklus? Sure, that wasn't at the Cliff Keen, but it was a legitimate match, nonetheless, and he looked great. That's exciting no matter what. Sure, we can't predict the future, but I see very little point in starting him in front of a likely AA when the advantage in team points with higher placement by Warner would have little impact on the team race.

The point is that starting a true freshman simply for the sake of starting a true freshman, or so fans can get a little extra excited, makes little sense. I have no doubt we'll be starting true freshmen who are ready and healthy, before long. We don't have a policy set in stone that says we won't. Recruits understand that. This is largely a non-issue, IMO. Given the current situation, I think having an eligible Jacob Warner several years from now is worth more than having him in the lineup this season. Also, remember that he barely beat Wilcke in the wrestle off. Sure, familiarity, yada, yada, yada, but Cash hung right with him. That speaks highly of Wilcke. Of course, it's ultimately up to him and the coaches, but I just don't see the point of burning the shirt at this juncture.
Is Cornell competing for a national title? Didn't stop Yianni from competing.
 
Is Cornell competing for a national title? Didn't stop Yianni from competing.
Does Cornell have a probable AA at his weight other than Yianni? I actually don't know, but I highly doubt it. Furthermore, Iowa and Cornell are an apple and an orange. Cornell is almost never competing for national titles, whereas Iowa is used to doing so and is working to get back on top. I don't think they're really comparable situations.
 
Know it is early but watching the CLV Ohio State looks tough.
Penn State best bet is to pull the shirt on N. Lee. I don't think
they can afford to not get few points this year from 125 to 141.
Couldn’t agree more. And given how great Yianni looks, Lee’s loss to him looks okay.

As an aside, Desanto destroying a lot of guys. Imagine a healthy S Lee (Sorry to poke that wound)
 
Cornell has Finger Lakes Community College wrestling team and Big Red Wrestling Club in lieu of Redshirting. Kyle Dake is a coach at Finger Lakes CC
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^THIS^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

And Tompkins Cortland Community College where they take "hard" classes that transfer and they still work out with the wrestling team. Macri, Dean, Palacios, Kolls kid and virtually every other wrestler does the same at Cornell.

Harvard sets kids in prep schools like Exeter Academy for a post-graduate year so they can develop athletically and academically.

Like I said, the Ivy is creative
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huck and Jaybird319
Not if he is already at Cornell. Can't redshirt him. Too late to greyshirt him. Might as well let him wrestle if he's the best guy.
But the wrestler can always withdraw from Cornell for a semester or whatever and do the steps outlined above and then "apply" for re-admittance the following year after working out with the club and taking community college classes that transfer into Cornell.

Doesn't have to be an Olympic redshirt
 
Ivy League. Red shirt is not an option.
Good point -- I'd forgotten that. Although Ivies do tend to get around the no-redshirt rule by grayshirting guys. I guess this makes Cornell and Iowa even more of an apple and an orange.
 
Does Cornell have a probable AA at his weight other than Yianni? I actually don't know, but I highly doubt it. Furthermore, Iowa and Cornell are an apple and an orange. Cornell is almost never competing for national titles, whereas Iowa is used to doing so and is working to get back on top. I don't think they're really comparable situations.
I guess we can defer this conversation until next year. At the end of the day we will leave it up to Brands and the wreslers to do what they think is best for the team and the individuals. I know this year is going to be a struggle and even if we put our best lineup out there we probably won't win a national title. Penn St only loses Retherford and will still be a force next year so we will see how we compete against them in 2018-2019. I just hate seeing us look this bad with a narrow victory over Illinois. Maybe I'm just overreacting to one dual early in the season. Right now I feel like Sorensen, Kemerer, and Stoll are our only likely AA's. Downey included if he pans out. Still puts us outside the top 5 IMO.
 
Just to clarify some things for some posters here cornell does not send guys to finger lakes community college. They also do not have any wrestling program there. Cornell sends most true freshman to Tompkins Cortland Community College (TC3) and those guys train at the finger lakes wrestling club. Also it is not too late for Yianni to have a grey shirt. If at any time he wants to use it he would have to take a year off from school. There’s been Ivy League guys who have already done it before.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huck and DirkTang1
Just to clarify some things for some posters here cornell does not send guys to finger lakes community college. They also do not have any wrestling program there. Cornell sends most true freshman to Tompkins Cortland Community College (TC3) and those guys train at the finger lakes wrestling club. Also it is not too late for Yianni to have a grey shirt. If at any time he wants to use it he would have to take a year off from school. There’s been Ivy League guys who have already done it before.
hey why didn't somebody mention that already in this thread?????????
 
This is the most frustrating part to me. We continually watch stud true freshman at other programs go out and beat top ranked guys while our guys have to “get bigger and stronger in the room”. Yianni beats a national runner up and is in the finals. Mark Hall wins a national title last year. Why do our former Wolrd Junior Champs have to redshirt? Especially when we have to watch our current guys get beat with little effort.

Drexel is not in a position to save up for anything. Maybe Desanto wanted to go right away. Lee is coming of an ACL injury. 197 pounders usually need a bit more time to fill out like the big boys. We don't know what Lee or Warner want to do but if they were cleared and insist on going right away I am sure you would see them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: andegre
Drexel is not in a position to save up for anything. Maybe Desanto wanted to go right away. Lee is coming of an ACL injury. 197 pounders usually need a bit more time to fill out like the big boys. We don't know what Lee or Warner want to do but if they were cleared and insist on going right away I am sure you would see them.
Speaking of DeSanto, to put things in perspective, he's pretty much killing it as a true freshman at 133, having just majored a complete stud in Micic and racking up the points in the process. Spencer took him on in the PA state finals last season after he dropped a weight class to create the match-up, with a torn ACL and mono, not having really even trained for over a month. . . and lost on a last-second somewhat controversial takedown. And just as an aside, there were people trying to talk Spencer out of even wrestling in the finals, as his body was pretty much shot by then, but he insisted -- not necessarily because he wanted to win the 4th state title and become an undefeated 4x state champ, but because he wanted the challenge and didn't want to miss the opportunity.

So this dynamo who's tearing it up in D1, a weight class up from Spencer, was barely able to beat him even with the benefit of basically being a weight class bigger (although yes, he did make the cut), Spencer having a torn ACL plus mono plus poor cardio due to having been unable to train leading up to State. That says a whole lot about what a special wrestler Spencer is. . . not to mention the kind of young man he is.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT