ADVERTISEMENT

*****Official Cubs 2023 thread*****

Bleacher Nation story with a connection to a Tommy Birch article in the DMR.
A very promising update on Brennen Davis, a best we could hope for update on Alexander Canario, and a tepid thumbs up to Amaya.
https://www.bleachernation.com/cubs...rennen-davis-has-no-limitations-at-this-time/
Amaya is really in full-on “prove-it” mode. At some point I’ll believe he’s healthy when I see him be healthy. I’m hopeful that he can at least be a bat at some point, but I can’t really invest in him at this point. There’s reason to be hopeful, but also years of evidence to not get too excited.
 
So much for the Devers fantasy. It was nice while it lasted.
Yeah, that seemed weird. They reached a deal on his arb number, then quickly signed an extension. There really seemed like a lot of friction growing in between him and the team. And, as an outsider, the Red Sox seem to be in a little bit of disarray.
Your Eric Hosmer fantasy came true today, however.
 
Yeah, that seemed weird. They reached a deal on his arb number, then quickly signed an extension. There really seemed like a lot of friction growing in between him and the team. And, as an outsider, the Red Sox seem to be in a little bit of disarray.
Your Eric Hosmer fantasy came true today, however.
That whole Devers thing was weird. I kind of wonder if the Sox were holding firm on a years/cost number and not budging and then the bad pub they got after they lost Bogaerts just forced their hand. What was being reported as friction and maybe bad feelings either gets completely wiped away by $300M or it wasn’t really that way before. My best guess is that Devers was just holding on a number.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lucas80
I still haven't seen any details of the Hosmer deal. I assume he was looking for a few protections. He's already going to get paid.
 
I don’t see David Ross giving the okay to add Bauer. Certainly he doesn’t get a say in all moves, but he would in this type of move.
 
Considering the scumbag Ricketts helped elect Trump (after trying to beat him in primaries) and Todd was his finance chair for 2020 I don't see them having a problem with signing Bauer given they feel that they can get him at a good value. I'm hoping some others who might be decent people say no
 
I still haven't seen any details of the Hosmer deal. I assume he was looking for a few protections. He's already going to get paid.
I read an article about the Hosmer signing that basically said the Cubs might try to trade Mervis since a lefty lefty 1st base combo isn't ideal. The thinking is that Hosmer and Wisdom will play 1st since it would be righty lefty.

I'll see if I can find the article. It was nothing concrete, mostly conjecture.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lucas80
I read an article about the Hosmer signing that basically said the Cubs might try to trade Mervis since a lefty lefty 1st base combo isn't ideal. The thinking is that Hosmer and Wisdom will play 1st since it would be righty lefty.

I'll see if I can find the article. It was nothing concrete, mostly conjecture.
My guess is he just wanted some no trade protections. That's about all he could insist on.
 
I read an article about the Hosmer signing that basically said the Cubs might try to trade Mervis since a lefty lefty 1st base combo isn't ideal. The thinking is that Hosmer and Wisdom will play 1st since it would be righty lefty.

I'll see if I can find the article. It was nothing concrete, mostly conjecture.
I saw one guy on Twitter (Michael Cerami, maybe, so it might have been Bleacher Nation) speculating about it, but I’ve literally seen nothing else on it. If there’s some big value on Mervis where they can trade him to get a power hitting 3B or a starting pitcher or something, maybe, but otherwise the whole idea just makes no sense. Hosmer is Mervis insurance, Wisdom will play somewhere against lefties and there’s a DH spot. Trading Mervis because they signed Hosmer just makes no sense.
 
I read an article about the Hosmer signing that basically said the Cubs might try to trade Mervis since a lefty lefty 1st base combo isn't ideal. The thinking is that Hosmer and Wisdom will play 1st since it would be righty lefty.

I'll see if I can find the article. It was nothing concrete, mostly conjecture.
Found it....
Trade bait?
 
Considering the scumbag Ricketts helped elect Trump (after trying to beat him in primaries) and Todd was his finance chair for 2020 I don't see them having a problem with signing Bauer given they feel that they can get him at a good value. I'm hoping some others who might be decent people say no
Pretty sure Bauer can only make the minimum this year. Question is which non contender adds him.
 
I saw one guy on Twitter (Michael Cerami, maybe, so it might have been Bleacher Nation) speculating about it, but I’ve literally seen nothing else on it. If there’s some big value on Mervis where they can trade him to get a power hitting 3B or a starting pitcher or something, maybe, but otherwise the whole idea just makes no sense. Hosmer is Mervis insurance, Wisdom will play somewhere against lefties and there’s a DH spot. Trading Mervis because they signed Hosmer just makes no sense.

Totally agree with this! Unless some other team values Mervis way more than any of us could imagine and gives us something really legit it just doesn't make sense.
 
Pretty sure Bauer can only make the minimum this year. Question is which non contender adds him.
Bauer can only make his money from the Dodgers plus league minimum this year. I think technically, a team could pay him more, but it would be deducted from what the Dodgers owe him, so that would just be dumb.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lucas80
Bauer can only make his money from the Dodgers plus league minimum this year. I think technically, a team could pay him more, but it would be deducted from what the Dodgers owe him, so that would just be dumb.
I'm curious if someone like the Pirates add him. It's not as if they have any fans to tick off anyways.
 
I'm curious if someone like the Pirates add him. It's not as if they have any fans to tick off anyways.
People say he won't get picked up, but I can see a team taking a flyer after his suspension is up, especially a team that could give him some starts, take a little heat, then flip him at the trade deadline.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ClarindaA's
People say he won't get picked up, but I can see a team taking a flyer after his suspension is up, especially a team that could give him some starts, take a little heat, then flip him at the trade deadline.
The issue still remains when will he blow up next. And how much damage he does. It's not question of if it's when. If he feels a teammate is dogging it or an Ump is squeezing him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hawkifann
The issue still remains when will he blow up next. And how much damage he does. It's not question of if it's when. If he feels a teammate is dogging it or an Ump is squeezing him.
Any team that picks him up is doing it with a timeframe of months? Not years. Any issues, and they cut him at the expense of the Dodgers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hawkifann
Any team that picks him up is doing it with a timeframe of months? Not years. Any issues, and they cut him at the expense of the Dodgers.
But you're assuming the damage he does is only limited to him. Totally can see him go F it and throw at someone's head. Or sucker punch a teammate. Ending someone else's career.
 
But you're assuming the damage he does is only limited to him. Totally can see him go F it and throw at someone's head. Or sucker punch a teammate. Ending someone else's career.
We will see, but he has a lot of incentive to be a good boy for awhile.
 
We will see, but he has a lot of incentive to be a good boy for awhile.
Hasn't stopped him before. See Cleveland and Zona. Both had high hopes of extending him to big money considering his service time. And both passed after blow ups.
 
The Score had the Cubs minor league director on today. Said they want to put both PCA and Mervis in a position to succeed when they arrive…meaning getting quality consistent at-bats prior to getting to Chicago. Also said Brennan Davis is full go at spring training.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lucas80
The Score had the Cubs minor league director on today. Said they want to put both PCA and Mervis in a position to succeed when they arrive…meaning getting quality consistent at-bats prior to getting to Chicago. Also said Brennan Davis is full go at spring training.
I don't expect it to happen, but if PCA got a cup of coffee in Chicago this season I would not be shocked. My hope for Davis is a full season at AAA with no setbacks, and Chicago in 2024.
 
I‘m not going to try to lay out the whole roster at this point, but expect the Cubs to carry the max 13 pitchers with 13 position players. Looking around, Happ, Bellinger, Suzuki, Morel, Swanson, Hoerner, Hosmer, Wisdom, Barnhart and Gomes are absolute locks on the position player’s side. That’s 10 of 13. In play for those last 3 roster spots are Madrigal, Velazquez, McKinstry, Mastrobuoni, Mervis, Davis and others.
 
Supposedly Hosmer has reverse splits as a lefty batter. That could still allow Mash to be the strong side platoon.

Against rhp both could get regular starts between 1b and dh then Velazquez and Hosmer vs lhp.

Any chance Velazquez mashes and forces regular ABs? He didn’t get enough last season imo.
 
I‘m not going to try to lay out the whole roster at this point, but expect the Cubs to carry the max 13 pitchers with 13 position players. Looking around, Happ, Bellinger, Suzuki, Morel, Swanson, Hoerner, Hosmer, Wisdom, Barnhart and Gomes are absolute locks on the position player’s side. That’s 10 of 13. In play for those last 3 roster spots are Madrigal, Velazquez, McKinstry, Mastrobuoni, Mervis, Davis and others.
I’ll be interested to see what happens with Madrigal. He’s never played a position other than 2B in the majors, so there isn’t natural position flexibility there, Hoerner is locked in at 2B and they have at least two other options for utility. Not sure he fits what they’re doing now.
 
I’ll be interested to see what happens with Madrigal. He’s never played a position other than 2B in the majors, so there isn’t natural position flexibility there, Hoerner is locked in at 2B and they have at least two other options for utility. Not sure he fits what they’re doing now.
I hear the White Sox are looking for a 2B.😉
 
I understand that he still has options.
Yep. Send him to AAA and try and develop a little power, and some better glove skills. The Cubs don't need a light hitting, bad second baseman. Especially with the new shift rules going into effect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheCainer
Good news is that P.J. Higgins apparently cleared waivers and was outrighted to Iowa. I would have hated for the organization to lose him. I'm almost certain that he'll end up back on the active roster sometime in '23. At this moment it's not a guarantee that either Gomes (club option) or Barnhart (player option) will be on the team in '24, so unless Amaya makes big strides this summer, P.J. might be our only in-house option at C in '24 at this point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lucas80
Good news is that P.J. Higgins apparently cleared waivers and was outrighted to Iowa. I would have hated for the organization to lose him. I'm almost certain that he'll end up back on the active roster sometime in '23. At this moment it's not a guarantee that either Gomes (club option) or Barnhart (player option) will be on the team in '24, so unless Amaya makes big strides this summer, P.J. might be our only in-house option at C in '24 at this point.
He‘s gone. He opted for free agency over taking the assignment. I have to think that Amaya’s status played big into even DFA-ing Higgins in the first place.

 
  • Like
Reactions: lucas80
D
He‘s gone. He opted for free agency over taking the assignment. I have to think that Amaya’s status played big into even DFA-ing Higgins in the first place.

Damn. Didn’t realize he had reached whatever status it is that allowed him to do that. I know he wasn’t essential to the immediate future, but I sure liked him as a player. And I hope you’re right about Amaya; you have a lot more confidence than I do.
 
D

Damn. Didn’t realize he had reached whatever status it is that allowed him to do that. I know he wasn’t essential to the immediate future, but I sure liked him as a player. And I hope you’re right about Amaya; you have a lot more confidence than I do.
It’s a years thing. When the Cubs DFA a bunch of guys after the season, several had the opportunity to opt out.

It’s not so much that I have huge confidence, it’s that as I look at the roster, I have to ask myself “If not PJ, then who?” There are some guys on the roster right now who won’t be with the org coming out of spring training, but I think there are some positional battles that the team wants to play out - like McKinstry vs. Mastrobuoni, for instance. There are also guys on the 40-man who may not contribute in Chicago, but are not getting cut for Higgins (Brown, Davis, Alcantara to name 3).

Higgins is a useful guy, no doubt, as he can play corner IF and catch (maybe even play some corner OF in a pinch), but I think this year, it’s more realistic to think the 2 catchers will be able to cover more of the play. Last year, we all know Willson was going to DH a good bit, so it was important to have Higgins around. This year, I think the Cubs are comfortable with Barnhart & Gomes splitting the season and if Amaya can be healthy for 5 min, maybe he could cover an IL stint or something. We’ll see. Who knows, maybe he’ll make the rounds and wind up back with the Cubs on a minor league deal.
 
...and Correa back to the Twins. Maybe things won't out with the Twins in a couple of weeks and he could still end up with the Cubs.
 
...and Correa back to the Twins. Maybe things won't out with the Twins in a couple of weeks and he could still end up with the Cubs.
6 yrs 200 million could Max out at 270 with vesting options. Question is how long will that ligament last before it blows. He's not a small guy. And SS is a high stress position unlike OF or DH.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT