Originally posted by Birky:
Anyway, only theiowahawk can confirm what he was talking about when he said "Metro." Theiowahawk, when you said "Metro," did you mean "The Des Moines Metro," or were you talking about the Ames-Des Moines SMSA? Only you know.
Not entirely sure why you are throwing this back to me, I listed Dallas, Polk, and Warren specifically.
I would define the Metro as the following suburbs/school districts:
Des Moines
West Des Moines
Waukee
Urbandale
Johnston
Ankeny
Altoona
SE Polk
I may be leaving out some others, but the point is that I would not consider: Ames, ADM, Indianola, etc. Soon we can even be including DCG and others that are getting pulled in.
LC is right in one regard, I used the word "absolutely" in saying there are more Hawkeye fans than ISU fans. I should have prefaced that with, "imo". Anecdotally, whatever. Sure there are more ISU signs/licenseplated/sweatshirts/hats/flags in the Metro than anywhere else in the state (including Ames), but that does NOT mean that there are more ISU fans than Iowa fans. As I stated my opinion earlier, it became the "in" thing to do in the last decade to be an ISU fan in the metro. I think this was for two reasons:
1) Pollard and his marketing
2) DM - ISU fans are, largely, graduates, people with good jobs and expendable income, and therefore are "unlike" the stereotypical ISU fans. They created a niche of fans that believe they were even above Iowa fans (often the type who call others "Tavern Hawks").
Am I saying this is objectively true? No, just my experience from living in various parts of the State and now residing in the metro.
Poo-poo the Facebook poll all you want, but "scientific" polls have been wrong, well, in every election cycle ever. It isn't like we have to agree on this.
I called out one highlighted piece of stupidity, someone claiming that ISU "owns" the metro and that (let me bold this), kids go to ISU over Iowa at a
5-1 clip. What astounding bullsht.
I'm taking a look at 12345's ISU pdf now. Seems to show a little over 25k alumni residing in Polk County, anyone know the number for Iowa? I asked earlier, but will ask again, how many members of the I-Club / Cy-Club?
Even taking the numbers that 12345 posted at face value, it ignores the fact that Ames is so much closer to Des Moines. Well, maybe it doesn't ignore it, it just doesn't acknowledge it. How many remain living in Polk? Does that mean that ISU is out-marketing Iowa? Maybe, but not necessarily. ISU may just be the most-feasible travel-option for those who stay at home. Good for ISU in that regard, it has improved significantly in the last 20 years as the Metro has greatly expanded north and more and more kids of that age have vehicles.
Every year Iowa and ISU put out, roughly, the same number of grads, therefore the Alumni difference isn't staggering. What we seem to be discussing is "fans", and I would hope everyone agrees that Iowa dwarfs that of ISU in that regard statewide.