ADVERTISEMENT

Carl Sagan on the Existence of God

As Carl Sagan said in the clip that (I'm guessing) few here actually watched, if you want to call the laws of nature "God" . . . go right ahead.

I mean we already have a perfectly good term for that, namely "the laws of nature" but "God" is easier to type.

Just remember that God, so defined, doesn't listen to prayers, grant salvation, or any of that nonsense.

If I accept the laws of nature as my Lord and Savior, do I get a prize?

You have some sort of spiking the football complex. Its just weird.
 
@JRHawk2003 you're wasting your time. @tarheelbybirth doesn’t believe in a creator or intelligent design . However we agree on the complexity of life and the wonders of our planet being just the right distance to the sun , all the natural systems in place etc to conclude there was intelligence in the creation of life. The evidence is there. People just choose to ignore it .
Romans 1:20 describes it perfectly :
For His invisible qualities are clearly seen from the world’s creation onward, because they are perceived by the things made, even His eternal power and Godship, so that they are inexcusable

Do we need the bold?

Look, I think all this type of stuff....like WWJD is doing, is a waste of time.

I dont look to science for the same answers and science tells me how stuff works, but it never answers why. It isn't concerned with why. Ian Malcolm wasn't wrong.
 
I have no idea what you mean by that. You can push the "God created the medium" angle...but that's just a god of the gaps - the idea that god exists in those areas of science we don't yet understand. That's a recipe for a god that gets smaller and smaller and smaller as science advances.

Science will never give meaning to anything. If you don't seek meaning, its all you need.
 
Science will never give meaning to anything. If you don't seek meaning, its all you need.
Yet, you've been arguing that there is "meaning" in the current gaps in scientific knowledge. That this absence somehow demonstrates the reality of a god. Seek your meaning where you will. Don't pretend that your way is the only path. Kinda smacks of arrogance.
 
  • Love
Reactions: strummingram
What people simply don’t understand is the world we live in currently is ruled by Satan and his demons .
They are responsible for the world conditions we live in now .
1st John 5:19-We know that we originate with God, but the whole world is lying in the power of the wicked one”
This is confirmed by the three temptations the Devil presented to Jesus after his baptism. The third offer tells us much
Matthew 4:8-Again the Devil took him along to an unusually high mountain and showed him all the kingdoms of the world and their glory. 9 And he said to him: “All these things I will give you if you fall down and do an act of worship to me”
One would ask how could Satan offer Jesus all the kingdoms of the world if he was not their ruler or owner.?
Fact is Satan is responsible for the cruelty and suffering we see on the earth today . He is also responsible for the God dishonoring lies we see within religion .

No. It's the RNC.
 
Yet, you've been arguing that there is "meaning" in the current gaps in scientific knowledge. That this absence somehow demonstrates the reality of a god. Seek your meaning where you will. Don't pretend that your way is the only path. Kinda smacks of arrogance.
And, it would help, immensely, to refrain from literal interpretation. It's obvious that anyone can make anything fit, if you need it to fit. But, you can't expect others... and NEVER SHOULD YOU NEED OTHERS... to do it thesame way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tarheelbybirth
Yet, you've been arguing that there is "meaning" in the current gaps in scientific knowledge. That this absence somehow demonstrates the reality of a god. Seek your meaning where you will. Don't pretend that your way is the only path. Kinda smacks of arrogance.
Dont straw man me.

I didnt say that at all. I said I search for meaning. I don't use science for that nor do I advocate that. Science is great and all. People can't use it responsibly, but that is another issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BHawkeye1999
Your interpretation of Scripture is far different from mine. That's another hole for so-called Bible literalists. There is no "one right way" to interpret Scripture.

I read this and have a completely different understanding:

5 They do not know or understand; they wander in the darkness; all the foundations of the earth are shaken. 6I have said, ‘You are gods; you are all sons of the Most High.’ 7 But like mortals you will die, and like rulers you will fall.”…

John 10:34
Jesus replied, "Is it not written in your Law: 'I have said you are gods'?

You have your way, I have mine. God neither punishes, nor rewards. God is not a "He" in my understanding. My God doesn't have, or need, a penis.

Why do religious-types quote Biblical scripture to non believers and the uninterested? The absurdity of the cryptic text is among the reasons for lack of belief.
 
  • Like
Reactions: artradley
Why do religious-types quote Biblical scripture to non believers and the uninterested? The absurdity of the cryptic text is among the reasons for disbelief.
I'm interested... and, in my own way, I definitely "believe." But, it's MY WAY of believing. Religious followers also have a "church" and their peers (other followers) to contain with. The church needs it to be a certain way so it can continue to be relevant. And, if the church goes away, then the "other followers" are soon to follow. So, those kinds of believers have to represent their churches and their fellow believers in situations like this. It's a tall order. And, of course, they usually believe God is a super-human, MALE parental figure that lives up in the sky. The liturgy absolutely describes such a thing, if you read The Bible.

But, if you go back through the thread, you'll see the Catholic fighting with the Jehovah's Witness over who believes "the right way." They quote Scripture, back and forth, trying to convince the other one that they're worshiping wrong, believing the wrong thing, pissing God off, headed to Hell, whatever. And, these are two people who "believe".

It's never a dull moment.
 
OK.

Who do you think He was?
First of all... I don't think He "was." I believe that he "IS."

And, after all I've experienced in life, I think that we're all capable of being like Him. In a way... in a really important way... we are all exactly like Him. He is Us and We are Him. It's all connected, and it will always be connected. It's all created out-of-and-through an eternal, universal Connection.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlackNGoldBleeder
Who do you think Jesus was?
A Middle Eastern rabbi with a, perhaps, revolutionary message whose teachings were subverted to control the masses. Render into Caesar his stuff...your reward will come after you die. Meanwhile, Caesar is living like...well...a caesar.
 
A Middle Eastern rabbi with a, perhaps, revolutionary message whose teachings were subverted to control the masses. Render into Caesar his stuff...your reward will come after you die. Meanwhile, Caesar is living like...well...a caesar.

Do you think He was a liar, lunatic or God in human form?
 
Do you think He was a liar, lunatic or God in human form?
I know this will be difficult, at first, because of what your church has taught you... but, aren't WE ALL "God in human form?" If we're not, then the whole basis of your religion is flawed.

They crucified Jesus, but allowed him to be the only one who was God. And, that's as far as they're willing to go, in practice. But, IN SCRIPTURE, Jesus tells us that WE are just like HIM. You don't need the church to have what you already have!
 
Because He said that He was God.

So either He was either lying, crazy or telling the truth.
You heard him talk? You are really older than I thought!

I say that I am God. I mean it! I say that YOU are God... and I MEAN THAT!

Am I lying? Am I crazy, or am I telling the truth?

Jesus did all of that and it caught-on, and then they killed him for it.
 
I know this will be difficult, at first, because of what your church has taught you... but, aren't WE ALL "God in human form?" If we're not, then the whole basis of your religion is flawed.

They crucified Jesus, but allowed him to be the only one who was God. And, that's as far as they're willing to go, in practice. But, IN SCRIPTURE, Jesus tells us that WE are just like HIM. You don't need the church to have what you already have!

No, we're not all God in human form, according to Christianity. Your religion is obviously different.
 
You heard him talk? You are really older than I thought!

I say that I am God. I mean it! I say that YOU are God... and I MEAN THAT!

Am I lying? Am I crazy, or am I telling the truth?

Jesus did all of that and he caught-on, and then they killed him for it.

Of those options, I think you're crazy.
 
No, we're not all God in human form, according to Christianity. Your religion is obviously different.
Well, yes, Christianity benefits from you believing that you're not God in human form. We are all God's creation. How that neuters being God in human form, don't know. But, I'm sure the church can explain it to you.

Jesus begged people to realize that if you can just open yourself to realize it, then you realize that You and God are the same thing. "I did it! And, you can do it, too!"
 
Well, yes, Christianity benefits from you believing that you're not God in human form. We are all God's creation. How that neuters being God in human form, don't know. But, I'm sure the church can explain it to you.

Jesus begged people to realize that if you can just open yourself to realize it, then you realize that You and God are the same thing. "I did it! And, you can do it, too!"

No.

I'm not God. That's nonsense.
 
Because He said that He was God.

So either He was either lying, crazy or telling the truth.
Are you sure? He's only said to make that claim in John - the last of the Gospels. The claim doesn't appear in ANY of the other Gospels nor in the writings of Paul...and you'd think he would write about that. Paul claiming that Jesus was God but separate from God would have been viewed as heresy before the Trinity was manufactured out of whole cloth.

Maybe whoever wrote John was a lunatic or a liar.
 
Are you sure? He's only said to make that claim in John - the last of the Gospels. The claim doesn't appear in ANY of the other Gospels nor in the writings of Paul...and you'd think he would write about that. Paul claiming that Jesus was God but separate from God would have been viewed as heresy before the Trinity was manufactured out of whole cloth.

Maybe whoever wrote John was a lunatic or a liar.

Yes. I think Jesus proved His divinity by resurrecting from the dead.

His apostles were killed for that belief with 0 reason to lie.
 
Yes. I think Jesus proved His divinity by resurrecting from the dead.

His apostles were killed for that belief with 0 reason to lie.
900+ people killed themselves and their children in service to a madman in Jonestown. Cults can make you do all kinds of strange, self-destructive things.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT