ADVERTISEMENT

Per CNN Regional Jet crashes in Potomac River

This also reminds me of a commercial flight in CA that hit a Cessna. San Diego area maybe? The jet was descending and could not see the Cessna putzing along below it practicing low visibility landings or something? Two pilots onboard, and the guy flying was wearing a hood
 
Im not a pilot or anything, but at that low of an altitude I’m wondering how well the collision avoidance systems/sensors even operate?
 
Below 1,000 feet (above ground level) it inhibits what is called a resolution advisory (RA). An RA is the hey dummy do this now before you hit the other plane. The 2 planes tcas systems talk to each other to ensure they move away. IE one might climb and the other descend. A RA is trigged when it senses the aircraft to be within 25 seconds of impact.

Prior to that you would get a TA, which you will STILL GET THIS below 1,000 feet. It’s a heads up dummy light/call. Yells at you in the cockpit to look for the other aircraft and be ready to maneuver to avoid. About 40 secs prior to collision.

When your TCAS goes off it’s hard to miss. It just yells at you. The target traffic lights up yellow and red on your display, in relation to you.

You cannot ignore an RA at all. You have to comply with the instruction given. But below 1k feet, you aren’t going to get it.

42763.jpg


Example of RA (they wouldn’t have received this below 1k feet, also this is Airbus. CRJ would be similar just displayed differently )
 
No, but I travel there frequently. Probably 3-4 times per year. Going there in a month. I live in KC so unlikely to fly out of Wichita but my Dad doesn't know regional flight patterns (like Wichita usually doesn't stop in KC)

I live in the area.
 
This also reminds me of a commercial flight in CA that hit a Cessna. San Diego area maybe? The jet was descending and could not see the Cessna putzing along below it practicing low visibility landings or something? Two pilots onboard, and the guy flying was wearing a hood
San Diego. Pacific Southwest 182.
 
Below 1,000 feet (above ground level) it inhibits what is called a resolution advisory (RA). An RA is the hey dummy do this now before you hit the other plane. The 2 planes tcas systems talk to each other to ensure they move away. IE one might climb and the other descend. A RA is trigged when it senses the aircraft to be within 25 seconds of impact.

Prior to that you would get a TA, which you will STILL GET THIS below 1,000 feet. It’s a heads up dummy light/call. Yells at you in the cockpit to look for the other aircraft and be ready to maneuver to avoid. About 40 secs prior to collision.

When your TCAS goes off it’s hard to miss. It just yells at you. The target traffic lights up yellow and red on your display, in relation to you.

You cannot ignore an RA at all. You have to comply with the instruction given. But below 1k feet, you aren’t going to get it.

42763.jpg


Example of RA (they wouldn’t have received this)

It doesn't sound like it's going to matter in this instance due to altitud4e, but I'm curious if military aircraft has this feature as well. I'm assuming they wouldn't because this could be picked up by the enemy.
 
It doesn't sound like it's going to matter in this instance due to altitud4e, but I'm curious if military aircraft has this feature as well. I'm assuming they wouldn't because this could be picked up by the enemy.
Yes they do but they usually don’t use it because of said reasons
 
Im not a pilot or anything, but at that low of an altitude I’m wondering how well the collision avoidance systems/sensors even operate?
Guess I skipped the original point of this question. They work fine all the way down. The issue is during normal operations into busy airports it could cause chaos with constant alerts with zero actual traffic issues with multiple parallel approaches occurring with departing aircraft as well. It assumes below 1k feet everything is SOP and flowing normal. DCA…little different. Sure we see changes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lucas80
It doesn't sound like it's going to matter in this instance due to altitud4e, but I'm curious if military aircraft has this feature as well. I'm assuming they wouldn't because this could be picked up by the enemy.
They do but often shut their transponder off during combat or tonight. Apparently, the helicopter transponder was off tonight.
 
Wow, just wow, many probably died and you bring up this crap?
Spare me your faux bullshit, libbity… not tge place for it. Just shut your mouth. Folks dude here. No need for your “witty repartee”…
Exactly...it was avoided a few billion times, it was only a matter of time before an accident hit.
A good friend’s son is a commercial pilot and he has commented that in/out of Reagan is “an accident waiting to happen”… way too much traffic for allotted airspace and it really gets busy at certain times of the day.
 
This shows the helo corridor there, and also shows how common it is for these aircraft to be in close proximity/heavy traffic there. You can see why ATC thought all was good after the helo confirmed visual (at least that’s what i thought I heard on the recordings)given how common this is.

Sounds like CRJ was at 400 feet at 140 mph. For those who survived initial impact (probably some), that split second fall is hard to comprehend. Sick to my stomach.
 
Last edited:
This shows the helo corridor there, and also shows how common it is for these aircraft to be in close proximity/heavy traffic there. You can see why ATC thought all was good after the helo confirmed visual given how common this is (at least that’s what i thought I heard on the recordings).

Sounds like CRJ was at 400 feet at 140 mph. For those who survived initial impact (probably some), that split second fall is hard to comprehend. Sick to my stomach.
Once an aircraft states they have traffic in sight and maintaining visual separation ATC has zero traffic spacing responsibility. That’s why even in a clear day setting lll never say traffic in sight. I’ll be a pain in their ass and let them keep us apart.
 
Im not even trying to be political but wtf does this even mean? What is he trying to get at? Can he just STFU right now. WH already said enough.



**** I have to go to bed. Flight out west tomorrow. Tomorrow is gonna suck.

He's an @sshole whose first instinct is to always flood the zone with bullshit to distract from the fact that mistakes were made. BAU.
 
Im not even trying to be political but wtf does this even mean? What is he trying to get at? Can he just STFU right now. WH already said enough.



**** I have to go to bed. Flight out west tomorrow. Tomorrow is gonna suck.
Ol’#47 just reminding his followers what a terrible burden his job is, fraught with danger. But he’s only doing it for their well-being. (Because ol’#47 is one helluva guy!). ;)
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT