The thing you are forgetting is counter attacking with the individual play of Davies and David is Canada's bread and butter. You can't counter attack a park the bus defense.
No, I got ya. I am not saying don't go defensive, I just thought it was TOO defensive. I would have gone with a 4-4-2 flat mid. One of the two center mids go forward to support when a forward holds up play. Outside backs do not go forward. Outside mids stay tucked in and don't go forward.
Don't let Davies or David beat you. Still doesn't let Buchanan feast in the middle. Kyle Layrn wasn't going to out duel any of our CBs, I didn't feel anyway.
Either way, just my line of thinking. Like I said, I can't argue the results. I just wanted to see more possession higher up the field. Pepi was just never in a good spot to get the ball and hold in the 5-4-1.
I also have some recency bias because I went against my gut and went to a 5-4-1 this season and we gave up 2 goals in the final 6 minutes to lose 2-1 because we couldn't keep any possession. Would have been our first win over a ranked 3A team and kept our conference title hopes alive. Ouch...