I know of a handful of elite level freshman that wrestled for Iowa as true freshman, that had the skills but had limited success that year and it affected them the rest of their careers.
Bart Chelsvig was the pound for pound #1 or 2 recruit and took his lumps as a true freshman and never really got back the where he was. Matt Fields and Alex Tsirtsis careers were impacted as well.
(Heck Throw Abe Assad in there as well)
But… there were some pretty high profile athletes that did well as true freshmen and continued to do well (Spencer Lee, Randy Lewis and Barry Davis). Daniel Dennis had a rough true freshman campaign and ended strong, but he was not considered an elite recruit like the previous 6 or 7.
How does Tom measure the mentality of the kid?
How will Drake respond to adversity and losses?
This will be where Tom earns his salary. It may work out well and Drake has an incredible career starting this year. Or he takes some lumps this year that he isn’t used to, and struggles to get back to where he is now.
Some kids need the year to develop, not because they aren’t physically ready for the success but that they aren’t ready for handling not having success.
I would keep the redshirt this year and wrestle Ybarra. Even with two reconstructed knees, there is no guarantee that Spencer will make it through next season either.
But, it is Drake’s and the staffs decision obviously.