My advice is to prey on the young. Get to them before they know better. Don't call it grooming or indoctrination either, those are no-go terms for your target audience. The magic and mysticism plays much better at that age too. Get to them before Harry Potter, LotR and GoT takes hold.
Don't be afraid to imitate either. MAGA has found millions of vulnerable people who will believe about anything. Go after them. If they'll swallow Qanon, they'll swallow anything JC did.
Use sports too. God is always favoring one team over another, allowing someone to make a catch and someone else to drop one. Use that for leverage.
People love coincidences too. Especially sports statistics and godly numbers. Know any good ones - Tebow? - that could be convincing to the reluctant believer/financial contributor.
Good luck and godspeed! Hopefully you'll have a successful Q1!