ADVERTISEMENT

From gambling allegations to this---Cody Chittum be gone? What's next?

What I believe was fumbled was off-hand comments made by Cael shortly after the injury occurred. He said something to the effect that the first time a wrestler suffers an injury in their career they don't know what they are capable of.

I think the Surianos saw people in the public taking Cael's statement as questioning Nick's manhood. Then there was a public backlash from the optics of him qualifying for NCAAs by stepping on the B1G Tournament mat.

I don't think PSU medical cleared Nick to actually compete at B1Gs or the NCAA. I don't believe Nick left because he thought he was well enough to compete at either.

I believe Nick left, in part, because he felt he was left hung out to dry in terms of public perceptions, which he rightly or wrongly attributed to how PSU communicated publicly about his injury. Other factors could have included disagreement on training approach between the Surianos and the PSU coaching staff, and how well Nick felt he fit in amongst his teammates.

Lastly, the Surianos could've believed that by stepping on the B1G mat, Nick could've substantially reduced his chances of getting a medical RS for that season.

Hopefully, all parties learned something from the experience.

I thought it has been well established that Nick left because he isn't a fan of dodgeball and was getting worked over in the dodgeball matches in the room.
 
Does a big ten head coach need to have experience as an assistant to be hired as an HC? Do they need a masters degree? Does Taylor have either? Honest questions as we have the “fire the coaches hire David Taylor” conversation often on our board as well 😂
Need? Or maybe want? I think you’d like to have someone that has experience in handling a college administration, the NCAA, Wrestler parents, the locker room, managing high-level wrestlers competing for the same spot, etc.
 
If Brands hadn’t finished top 5 essentially every year, just won a couple years ago and taken a clear 2nd just last year, I could see it. You guys are acting like Iowa has been terrible and you MUST have a change.

You honestly think Taylor is coming in and beating PSU? If not, you are replacing the clearly 2nd best for an unproven staff to hopefully take what??……2nd place! There is NO real upside, with a solid possibility of it failing.

The logic is soooo flawed it’s laughable!
On the flipside:

I think Iowa's floor, if you just had the median coaching in Division I wrestling, is what they have achieved since 2011.

In other words, I question the value that the Brands add to the effort/equation.
 
Not to mention, Iowa is the second most well funded program. It's not a level playing field between schools. I think there are a lot of coaches who could succeed at Iowa. There are also a lot who could come here and put the program in a worse position than with the current staff.

Regardless, it's a moot point anyway because there is exactly a 0% chance that Barta fired T&T. They'll be here for the remainder of their contracts at minimum. If anyone is hoping for coaching staff changes, the only chance is with the assistants/HWC. That's just the reality.

I would be pretty shocked if Gary Barta even knew who David Taylor was.
Like it or not, this is the reality. TnT are likely the coaches for as long as they want, especially if we keep packing Carver.

Time to get comfortable hoping for 2nd/3rd until Cael retires.

I feel nauseous.
 
"Anthony Ferrari's commitment and his plans to join the program — he has not officially signed yet, but projects at 157/165 — rubbed Chittum the wrong way. He didn't dive into details in his brief conversation with the Register, but he allowed that he'd rather leave Iowa City than be teammates with the Ferraris."

That is all the sense there is to be made of it.
 

For anybody doubting the "Ferrari Effect".

"
Things changed in March, when Anthony Ferrari announced his commitment to the Hawkeyes.

Ferrari, who announced his commitment on Instagram, is the middle Ferrari brother, between oldest brother A.J. and younger brother Angelo. They are all talented wrestlers, but the two oldest brothers have been marred by off-the-mat issues.

Anthony Ferrari's commitment and his plans to join the program — he has not officially signed yet, but projects at 157/165 — rubbed Chittum the wrong way. He didn't dive into details in his brief conversation with the Register, but he allowed that he'd rather leave Iowa City than be teammates with the Ferraris."
 
The Ferrari story is cover for "ISU offered more $"

bullshit GIF
 
"They"?

Terry never coached VT and may never have. I guess hypothetically they were primed in some alternate universe.

Terry was HC at the University of Tennessee-Chattanooga (2002-05) then Olympic Training center (2005-2008). This spans Tom's 2-year stint at VT (2004-2006).
Seriously? Do you want to argue just to argue now? I am pretty confident Terry would have ended up with Tom at some point, regardless of where it was. He has gone on record as saying he hated the CEO part of the Head Coach position.

Either way, "TOM" had VTech ready to go. Whenever/if ever Terry followed, I think they would have done nearly as well as Cael was doing at ISU...
 
Seriously? Do you want to argue just to argue now? I am pretty confident Terry would have ended up with Tom at some point, regardless of where it was. He has gone on record as saying he hated the CEO part of the Head Coach position.

Either way, "TOM" had VTech ready to go. Whenever/if ever Terry followed, I think they would have done nearly as well as Cael was doing at ISU...
Will you never just admit you miswrote (aka made an honest mistake)? 🤣
 
  • Haha
Reactions: pish69
To be CLEAR TO ALL, I am NOT saying that many of the TNT criticisms are unwarranted. Most are. What I have issue with is those calling for their replacement WITHOUT a clear candidate that can do as well, let alone achieve the nearly impossible task of dethroning PSU.

Mind you, even if you think DT is a Gable/Cael like ''generational coach", he hasn't done a THING as a DI coach. Remember, NEITHER Gable nor Sanderson were given Iowa or PSU without first gaining coaching experience at the DI level. On top of that, he is still competing. At the very least you make sure he is done and 100% dedicated to coaching before you even consider that hire...
 
Last edited:
Will you never just admit you miswrote (aka made an honest mistake)? 🤣
Trust me, I am as hard on myself as ANYONE. I just replied to the TNT post about them somewhere else.. I was well aware of where both were when Tom was at VTech. Hell my post even elaborated as to why.

I will happily say it was just Tom at VTech at the time. You want to call that a "mistake". Sure, I will gladly own that. But, I DID know exactly where both were at the time, so it isn't exactly the mistake you want it to be...
 
When chittum verbally committed but never signed, I told people on here I will believe him wrestling for Iowa when I see it. So although I do think TNT have mismanaged things, I am not certain that chittum was ever all in. Also, I will guess, as others have, that he doesn't use all of his eligibility at ISU.
 
With Spencer’s mismanagement, I am speaking to them waiting 9 months to get his knee repaired on. Just completely idiotic.

I don’t remember Eierman’s situation exactly but your training is what helps you prevent injuries. Iowa is clearly doing something wrong.
You think the coaches had anything to do with that?
 
Trust me, I am as hard on myself as ANYONE. I just replied to the TNT post about them somewhere else.. I was well aware of where both were when Tom was at VTech. Hell my post even elaborated as to why.

I will happily say it was just Tom at VTech at the time. You want to call that a "mistake". Sure, I will gladly own that. But, I DID know exactly where both were at the time, so it isn't exactly the mistake you want it to be...
👍. I understand. You have a reputation and backstory to maintain.
 
👍. I understand. You have a reputation and backstory to maintain.
Backstory? For real? You realize I was posting on themat back when Metcalf was at VTech, right? I was coaching in Michigan at the time Metcalf was in High School. I followed him rather closely. I was fully aware of his recruiting and who was there at the time.

Even when I was wrestling, I had a TON of respect for both Brands. I then thought the intensity of Tom was perfect to match Brent's. Add in the fact that I was very unhappy with how MSU wrestling was going and the Athletic Department wanted no part of anything I said(still don't, although I feel Roger and Chris are doing about as well as they can for what they are working with) and I found someone else to root for.

Hell, if they stayed at VTech, there is a pretty good chance I wouldn't even be posting on here now...
 
On the flipside:

I think Iowa's floor, if you just had the median coaching in Division I wrestling, is what they have achieved since 2011.

In other words, I question the value that the Brands add to the effort/equation.
Jim Zalesky VEHEMENTLY disagrees...
 
Imagine for a moment this isn’t a young mans decision, but an overbearing fathers who was trying to leverage a better “deal” for his son, but ended up sabotaging his sons career for his own ego in the process.. This is far from as simple a situation as Chittum vs Ferraris…. Matter of fact that had very little to do with this situation at all. That’s just the propaganda being pushed by the haters.

I feel very, very sorry for Cody Chittum and pray that one day he’ll get to make decisions for himself.
That sounds more like it, Ferrari’s have had minimal contact with our program, and Anthony’s visit seemed to go well with what he posted on instagram. Seeing this is a big second chance for him, I doubt he is dumb enough to start a fight with Iowa’s top recruit. Chittum has moved around a lot starting in high school. On 3rd college now before ever enrolling in college. Kind embarrassing clones could out bud us. Reminds me alittle of that football player switching to Alabama last minute for better offer, but at least he also went to better team. He could have been an important piece of championship team in a few years, that isn’t happening in Ames, especially after Carr leaves. Hope Ferrari’s did fall in love with jersey again. There had to be a reason they left.
 
Jim Zalesky VEHEMENTLY disagrees...
3 team titles in 9 years.

Reality is that Brands would kill for that kind of success since 2011.

I don't think either are better than about what the median coach in D1 is by the way. Just guys, no better or worse.
 
That sounds more like it, Ferrari’s have had minimal contact with our program, and Anthony’s visit seemed to go well with what he posted on instagram. Seeing this is a big second chance for him, I doubt he is dumb enough to start a fight with Iowa’s top recruit. Chittum has moved around a lot starting in high school. On 3rd college now before ever enrolling in college. Kind embarrassing clones could out bud us. Reminds me alittle of that football player switching to Alabama last minute for better offer, but at least he also went to better team. He could have been an important piece of championship team in a few years, that isn’t happening in Ames, especially after Carr leaves. Hope Ferrari’s did fall in love with jersey again. There had to be a reason they left.

You are really not good at reading tea leaves.

3 team titles in 9 years.

Reality is that Brands would kill for that kind of success since 2011.

You can't ignore his team finishes at the NCAAs. It shows there's a floor below being where we have been (2nd).
 
3 team titles in 9 years.

Reality is that Brands would kill for that kind of success since 2011.

I don't think either are better than about what the median coach in D1 is by the way. Just guys, no better or worse.
Seriously? Add context. Zalesky INHERITED probably Gable's best team of his entire career. Once those guys graduated, Iowa dropped quite fast. Hell, by the end of his career, Zalesky was losing to Northwestern. There is NO argument that Zalesky was on track to keep Iowa a trophy team every year, let alone get back on top like Brands did in 2020 and 2021.
 
3 team titles in 9 years.

Reality is that Brands would kill for that kind of success since 2011.

I don't think either are better than about what the median coach in D1 is by the way. Just guys, no better or worse.

Tom won 3 when he had a double recruiting class, and 1 in the last 11 years.

Brands- 8,1,1,1,3,3,4,4,2,5,4,3,4,1,3,2
Zalesky- 1,1,1,2,4,8,2,7,4

Zalesky won 3 and then was fired after 6 seasons without a title. Brands has won 1 title in the last 12 years.
 
Seriously? Add context. Zalesky INHERITED probably Gable's best team of his entire career. Once those guys graduated, Iowa dropped quite fast. Hell, by the end of his career, Zalesky was losing to Northwestern. There is NO argument that Zalesky was on track to keep Iowa a trophy team every year, let alone get back on top like Brands did in 2020 and 2021.
Again, I don't like or dislike either guy. They're just guys though, JZ and TB, as coaches.

I think it's also important to put context on Iowa in the Brands era another way: PSU has won 10 national titles since 2011. Those years, Iowa has finished runners up 2 times. It's not even just this PSU juggernaut keeping them from Iowa glory. They are in the thick of a lot of other teams chasing.

Anyway, it's real simple to me, Iowa can keep TB or some assistant/variant and win 1 or 2 a decade while PSU cares about wrestling, or they can change their philosophy and try to actually get on equal footing. It's not like Iowa is going to fall back to 8th annually either way.
 
Again, I don't like or dislike either guy. They're just guys though, JZ and TB, as coaches.

I think it's also important to put context on Iowa in the Brands era another way: PSU has won 10 national titles since 2011. Those years, Iowa has finished runners up 2 times. It's not even just this PSU juggernaut keeping them from Iowa glory. They are in the thick of a lot of other teams chasing.

Anyway, it's real simple to me, Iowa can keep TB or some assistant/variant and win 1 or 2 a decade while PSU cares about wrestling, or they can change their philosophy and try to actually get on equal footing. It's not like Iowa is going to fall back to 8th annually either way.
Careful what you wish for. The wrong coach can EASILY drop them down to 8th. You act like Iowa is an "easy" job because of its notoriety. The actual fact is, very much the opposite. The Brand BLEED Black and Gold. Good luck finding another truly qualified staff that feels the same.

Let's say you go get David Taylor. With PSU loaded like they are now, when do you realistically think he gets Iowa competing with them? By that time, Cael decides to retire. DT takes that job and nearly all his recruits at Iowa follow him. What happens to Iowa then? Because, make no mistake, DT would leave for PSU in a heartbeat and no one could blame him.

My contention with most on here is the armchair style in which coaching at the DI level is gauged. The amount of work that goes into it is beyond ridiculous. Add on NIL now and the coach has to become a salesman and housemom more than a coach. Even then, kids can transfer if they don't like the way their fart smelled during practice.
 
Tom won 3 when he had a double recruiting class, and 1 in the last 11 years.

Brands- 8,1,1,1,3,3,4,4,2,5,4,3,4,1,3,2
Zalesky- 1,1,1,2,4,8,2,7,4

Zalesky won 3 and then was fired after 6 seasons without a title. Brands has won 1 title in the last 12 years.
Zalesky was absolutely an inferior coach to Brands. Brands is not doing especially well these days either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: YoungGun07
Backstory? For real? You realize I was posting on themat back when Metcalf was at VTech, right? I was coaching in Michigan at the time Metcalf was in High School. I followed him rather closely. I was fully aware of his recruiting and who was there at the time.

Even when I was wrestling, I had a TON of respect for both Brands. I then thought the intensity of Tom was perfect to match Brent's. Add in the fact that I was very unhappy with how MSU wrestling was going and the Athletic Department wanted no part of anything I said(still don't, although I feel Roger and Chris are doing about as well as they can for what they are working with) and I found someone else to root for.

Hell, if they stayed at VTech, there is a pretty good chance I wouldn't even be posting on here now...
Yes. That's the kind of backstory I was referring to, albeit with a few more details. There's no negative connotation to the term "backstory" that I'm aware of. It's like a super hero "origin" story.

But you could admit, all of it taken into consideration, it was funny for you to write in a way that indicated both Tom and Terry were primed at VT. But since you didn't, sure enough more backstory, and again with the "if they stayed."
 
Yes. That's the kind of backstory I was referring to, albeit with a few more details. There's no negative connotation to the term "backstory" that I'm aware of. It's like a super hero "origin" story.

But you could admit, all of it taken into consideration, it was funny for you to write in a way that indicated both Tom and Terry were primed at VT. But since you didn't, sure enough more backstory, and again with the "if they stayed."
a history or background, especially one created for a fictional character in a motion picture or television program.

If that isn't what you meant, use a different word that fits better.

I replied to some that used TNT somewhere else as a possible knock and I said , "I think they were prime to do VERY well at VTech." "They" can be singular, if you want to be an ass. Still, they WERE prime to do well there and I do 100% stand by thinking Terry would eventually follow him anywhere.

Primed-make (something) ready for use or action. VTech was in fact primed to do well.

Regardless, I find it beyond comical that you follow me all over here and think you are somehow going to tell me how I think and feel, let alone how I did 16 years ago. Thanks for your help!
 
Let's say you go get David Taylor. With PSU loaded like they are now, when do you realistically think he gets Iowa competing with them? By that time, Cael decides to retire. DT takes that job and nearly all his recruits at Iowa follow him. What happens to Iowa then? Because, make no mistake, DT would leave for PSU in a heartbeat and no one could blame him.
I try to advise my niece, a Millenial who suffers from a lot of anxiety, that rather than get wrapped around negative future realities that are contrived only from her mental gymnastics, maybe she'd feel a lot better if she only tried to live in the moment more and take life as it comes.

Step 1 - Would be to see whether there is mutual interest on DT's part, and if not now when there might be.

Anything beyond this step would seem a fruitless exercise in the creation of pure negative fantasy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lookleft goright
Others have said Anthony did not get past admissions and is not going to be a Hawk now and Angelo has not committed either. AJ is not really even a possibility currently. Why would Chittum flip his commit based on something that hasn't happened? There has to be more to his flip than the possibility of Anthony coming to Iowa as it doesn't sound like that is happening anyway. Find it hard to believe a recruit is too "all in" if he flips from the possibility of another guy he wants nothing to do with joining the team. If none of the sports car brothers are coming, or only Angelo at the most, why still leave? Has to be more to the story.
 
Others have said Anthony did not get past admissions and is not going to be a Hawk now and Angelo has not committed either. AJ is not really even a possibility currently. Why would Chittum flip his commit based on something that hasn't happened? There has to be more to his flip than the possibility of Anthony coming to Iowa as it doesn't sound like that is happening anyway. Find it hard to believe a recruit is too "all in" if he flips from the possibility of another guy he wants nothing to do with joining the team. If none of the sports car brothers are coming, or only Angelo at the most, why still leave? Has to be more to the story.
In another thread (maybe?) It was mentioned that Dad Chittum shopped around for NIL deals and ISU had a better one. TB said, "no thanks" to the Chittum clan, after that.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT