Way to prove my point that this is a political discussion and not a scientific one
Girls left in dust as male-born transgender athletes take state track titles in five states
- Thread starter NorthernHawkeye
- Start date
Embarrassment is a foreign concept to kids these days. They’ve been told since birth that everything they do is perfect.
Post all the studies that demonstrates clear advantage then. You're the making this assertion.
I'm just saying all trans aren't equal. Putting them all together still isn't fair.
A born boy that's now a girl will be faster than a born girl that's now a boy.
Well that's great because I heard Lebron James, Jon Jones, and Shohei Ohtani are switching genders. I'll let the female athletes in their respective sports know that Huey Grey on HROT said they have no advantage.Let's get honest. The opposition to trans athletes is political not scientific. If you want to claim that trans athletes should be banned because of political or cultural reasons, have at it. But what you cannot claim is that it's because of scientific reasons. Because science can find no clear advantage.
New report finds that trans women athletes have no unfair advantage in elite sports — Mount Holyoke News
By Emily Tarinelli ’25 Sports Editor For the first time ever, a report titled “Transgender Women Athletes and Elite Sport: A Scientific Review” has shown that no existing scientific literature has proven trans women to have inherent competitive advantages over cisgender women in high-performancewww.mountholyokenews.com
Transition doesn’t change their inherent DNA advantages you Trans Cult grifter.
Explain to me how this works? The overwhelming odds are that there will be only one trans athletes at any given competition. Do they run a race all by themselves? What about competitions like basketball, volleyball, or wrestling? Are they completely barred from competing?
Post the studies. If it's clear that they have an advantage it should be easy for you.
Do you truly believe this stupid stance you're taking or is it a stance you are taking since you are a part of the LGBTQIA$?2+#% community??
Didn't you read the study from the Canadian Centre for Ethics in Sport he linked?????
There's no advantage!
It's science bitch!
There's no study because everyone with half of a brain isn't going to waste time and money on something so phucking obvious.
this needs to keep on happening until november so trump can mention it in his campaign and so trump may win
Still waiting on your studies. Where are they? Or have we shifted to the personal insults portion of the thread?
I am shocked a scientific study funded by a Canadian agency which prides itself on equity, safety and inclusion found no “competitive advantage”
Also they reference “elite sports” let’s take it for what it’s worth. Most of the news we see looks at high school and college in America. I would say a far cry from “elite”
Also they reference “elite sports” let’s take it for what it’s worth. Most of the news we see looks at high school and college in America. I would say a far cry from “elite”
Lol. Thank you for conceding that you're basing your arguments on feelings and not facts.
See. OIT gets it. Even he admits this is a political issue and not a biological one.
You are reading into my post too much.
I'm not saying we NEED four freaking categories.
I was just simply saying that even if trans athletes were given their own category, it still wouldn't be 100% fair.
THAT IS ALL I'M SAYING. Nothing more nothing less.
I don't need a study. Serena Williams the greatest woman tennis player admitted herself that she cannot compete against men. She once played against I believe an amateur male and she lost 6-1, 6-0.
It's too obvious for a study.
Also I didn't insult you. I asked if you actually believe taking this awful stance on men competing in women's sports is actually correct or if it's because you are a part of the community that 95% of the time defends it. It was a question.
So stop attempting to use current science as a way to resolve what is clearly a social, not political, issue...
You can't be this stupid. Can you?
Explain how a born male athlete is AVERAGE at best when competing against their born sex.
Then goes to DOMINATING against the opposite born sex.
Btw, there are definitely studies out there that show how males perform better than females. Google it.
Do you even watch sports?
Watch an NBA game and then switch to the WNBA. Report back.
Compare track times. Compare swimming times.
No advantage? LMFAO
It wouldn't be fair. It wouldn't be feasible. The mechanics of a trans only category aren't workable even if you wanted to create such a category.
Another link with other studies. They all say the same. No clear advantage. You can argue with me but when you argue with science you start to look silly.
Do transgender athletes have a competitive advantage over cisgender athletes?
Among the many questions surrounding this topic, one has risen to the top - do transgender girls actually have an advantage over cisgender girls in athletics?
www.cbs8.com
Cool. Another poster who agrees that this is a social issue and not biological one! We're making progress!
Exactly.
Michelle Wie missed the cut when trying to play on the PGA.
Annika Sorenstam the same.
There's not one WNBA player that could play on the NBA. Not one.
No, if you CHOOSE to transition, sports might just have to be a sacrifice you're willing to make.
This a tough issue. I can see both sides of the argument. What if a boy wrestler wants to transition so he can beat up on female wrestlers?
I don't know I'm pro supporting folks, but this seems to be a bit far.
I don't know I'm pro supporting folks, but this seems to be a bit far.
Women compete with women,.. Men compete with men, men who are transitioning to women, and women who are transitioning to men,.. If at any point in your life you either were male, or are now moving towards maleness, you compete with men,.. Easy peasy.
Last edited:
But I thought there was zero advantage based on gender. Why wouldn't a trans category be ok?
Another link with other studies. They all say the same. No clear advantage. You can argue with me but when you argue with science you start to look silly.
Do transgender athletes have a competitive advantage over cisgender athletes?
Among the many questions surrounding this topic, one has risen to the top - do transgender girls actually have an advantage over cisgender girls in athletics?
I don't even know how to respond to someone as clueless as you regarding this topic.
You are probably an intelligent person, but NOT on this topic.
No offense, but take off your gay blinders.
Or better yet. What if a trans boy is forced to compete against girls because a state like Texas wrote a law forcing athletes to compete as their born sex?
You mean a girl has to play girl sports? Say it isn't so!
It’s Huey against the world again. How soon until we’re all labeled fascist MAGATs?
Well that example is also phucked up because she was taking testosterone.
Which in most sports is a banned PED.
Right? They're so worried about shit that doesn't matter, like healthcare and the economy. Trans women competing in high school races is right up there with those issues!!
And no, I don't it's fair that trans females compete against other females. I also don't think government should be involved in it either way. It should be up the local sports organizations to determine whether or not to allow it.
No offense but you weren't even aware that right wing Texas undercuts some of your arguments in this thread. It's ok to admit that you're just making stuff up here.
That's because she was on testosterone. Big difference.
