Damn...this thread fell to Page 6 on Trump Testifying Day...
A play-by-play account of Monday's proceedings in Donald Trump's fraud trial.
www.forbes.com
9:57 a.m.: Donald Trump is in the courtroom, seated at the defense table, between his lawyers Chris Kise and Alina Habba. Judge Arthur Engoron is here, too, sitting at his perch.
10:00 a.m.: “We have a lot of people here and apparently a lot of photographers outside who want to photograph some of you,” the judge says.
10:03 a.m.: “The people call Donald J. Trump.” The former president walks to the stand and puts his right hand in the air. He settles in at his chair on the witness stand. Questioning him: Kevin Wallace of the attorney general’s office.
10:07 a.m.: They are going over the structure of the Donald J. Trump Revocable Trust, through which the former president owns his assets. Trump confirms that he remains the “sole beneficiary” of the trust, confirming that the trust is merely a shell entity. Yes, his sons could act on his behalf, but there was no question who was the ultimate boss—Donald Trump.
10:08 a.m.: When asked why he made his very-much-adult son, Don Jr., a trustee of the trust, the former president responds: “He’s a hardworking boy—young man.”
10:13 a.m.: Trump’s voice is muted and measured, by his standards. He is still criticizing his legal opponents, but he seems to be intentionally striking a softer tone than he does for the cameras.
10:17 a.m.: The former president is offering long-winded answers. The judge seems to be losing patience. “I would like to move things along a little faster,” he says. “Please, just answer the questions—no speeches.”
10:22 a.m.: The attorney general’s office pulls up the document below, which is part of the net-worth statement that the Trump Organization helped assemble. It pins the net-worth documents on Trump himself: “Donald J. Trump is responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of the financial statement in accordance with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of America.” It is this sort of documentation that makes it difficult for Trump to distance himself from the hyped-up documents at the center of this case.
Screenshot from one of Donald Trump's net-worth statements.
.
10:30 a.m.: Trump claims that he thought his penthouse was listed with too high of a value on the net-worth statements. “I thought the apartment was overvalued when I looked at it,” he claimed. This is not even remotely credible. Let’s dig into the numbers a bit.
10:42 a.m.: The calculations behind Donald Trump’s net-worth statements show a decrease in the penthouse value in 2017. What caused that drop? A change in square footage. The statements had previously listed Donald Trump’s penthouse at 30,000 square feet. They reduced it to 10,996 square feet. Trump has tried to make it seem like he was responsible for that change. Nonsense. The Trump Organization changed the square-footage figure only after
Forbes exposed the fact that the size was overstated, with a story titled
“Donald Trump Has Been Lying About The Size Of His Penthouse.”
10:45 a.m.: Donald Trump, when trying to pump up his net worth in conversations with
Forbes, had previously touted the number of square feet at 33,000, an even bigger number than the inflated 30,000 square feet listed on his statements. Make no mistake: The inflated square footage of the penthouse his lie, not someone else’s.
10:50 a.m.: Judge Engoron has clearly lost his patience with Trump, as the former president drags out answer after answer. “Mr. Kise,” the judge says to Trump’s lawyer at one point, “can you control your client?”
10:55 a.m.: Trump’s lawyers are telling the judge to basically treat Trump like he gets treated in media appearances—to sit back and listen to what he has to say, then make of it what he’d like. “I’m not here to hear what he has to say,” the judge roars, explaining that he’s here to hear his answers to specific questions. “Sit down, already,” he says to Trump’s legal team at one point.
10:57 a.m.: That prompts Trump to lash out from the witness stand. He speaks in a neutral tone, but his frustration is unmistakable: “This is a very unfair trial—very, very,” the former president says.
11:01 a.m.: Kevin Wallace of the attorney general’s office says he would like to take a brief break and asks Trump’s lawyer, Chris Kise, to please speak with his client.
11:09 a.m.: The sparring that we are seeing between Trump and the judge was entirely predictable. Judge Engoron has been adamant throughout this case that witnesses answer yes-or-no questions with yes-or-no answers. Trump is not accustomed to that sort of format. He is a master of giving rambling, oftentimes interesting, responses to questions. Doing so allows him to avoid being pinned down and to project confidence. He gets away with this in media appearances. All reporters interviewing Trump know they have a limited amount of time, so they might press him a bit, but ultimately, they’ll move on to other questions. That doesn’t work in a courtroom, where witnesses must answer specific questions under oath.
11:14 a.m.: “All rise!” court is back in session. Everyone sits down but Trump, who strolls up to the witness stand.
11:17 a.m.: The state is questioning Trump about Seven Springs, a mansion in New York that was one of the most egregiously inflated assets on his net-worth statements. Even Trump admits it wasn’t worth the $291 million listed on his statements. “I thought it was high,” he says.
11:20 a.m.: Kevin Wallace of the attorney general’s office turns to two office towers, 1290 Avenue of the Americas and 555 California Street, in which Trump owns a 30% interest. Trump continues to give meandering responses when Wallace asks whether he controls the partnership. “Well, in many ways it’s better,” Trump begins, before saying that his minority interest limits his liability exposure. He does not answer the original question until Wallace asks again. This sort of thing is happening over and over.