ADVERTISEMENT

Uh Oh......Russia agrees to 30 day cease-fire.

Not a callout of you, or Lucas.

I just don’t get this take that we’re fighting some proxy war, at the expense of other countries citizens dying, for our supposed benefit.

Feels gross.
Russia put this into motion, and without US assistance, combined with that of other nations, Russia woukd have seized far more territory and killed far more people. They’d also have destabilized Europe even more. They weren’t stopping at Kiev and Odessa.
 
from what i’ve gathered russia has seized all the territory it wanted to seize — someone correct me if i’m wrong but all of the seized territory has overwhelmingly russian language majority. if russia tries for more they’ll be beset with internal strife and insurgency from ukranians which will be the worst outcome possible for them. so a ceasefire on paper should be a long lasting one if achieved
 
  • Like
Reactions: HawkeyeShawn
Trump deserves some credit for getting the parties to the table. But (and it is a BIG but), this doesn’t mean the war is over. And there is a big risk he coerces Ukraine into a position that ultimately helps Russia.

We shall see if this leads to a peace that is viable for Ukraine or whether he screws them over.

But it is a start and I will give him props for that.
How can Trump screw them over? They either agree to a deal or they don't. They decide. He got a 30 day cease fire and them negotiating, now it is up to them to settle things.
 
How much money should we spend on a foreign war that doesn't involve us? Is there a limit? In my opinion, we should stop sending them support, we have spent enough.
It's not money; it's military equipment, much of which is outdated or will soon be outdated. And military intelligence was also withdrawn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: McLovin32
How can Trump screw them over? They either agree to a deal or they don't. They decide. He got a 30 day cease fire and them negotiating, now it is up to them to settle things.
By withholding satellite communications. By pausing the sharing of intel. By reneging on promises/backstabbing them on whatever agreement is reached.

There are a million and one ways he could screw them over. Trump is not, and never has been, a man of his word. He lies for a living. All parties could agree on a deal. They could operate to the letter of the law against that deal and Trump may still change things on a whim.

Now, if you weren’t paying attention for the last 8 years I could understand why this might seem far fetched. But just look at the last couple weeks for a prime example of this - the USMCA.

Trump negotiated the USMCA deal that he has now broken. It wasn’t broken by Canada first, they followed the deal. Trump decided he didn’t like it anymore and unilaterally created a trade war. He follows this same pattern over and over again. He is not trustworthy. So yes, he very well may screw them over.
 
from what i’ve gathered russia has seized all the territory it wanted to seize — someone correct me if i’m wrong but all of the seized territory has overwhelmingly russian language majority. if russia tries for more they’ll be beset with internal strife and insurgency from ukranians which will be the worst outcome possible for them. so a ceasefire on paper should be a long lasting one if achieved
Russia wants a land bridge to Transnistria and to cut Ukraine off completely from the Black Sea. They also tried to take Kiev and occupied Chernobyl.

It's argued they don't have the current military might to go further unless they regroup and rearm. Which a ceasefire would provide. It's why them keeping Russian speaking areas is so untenable long term. It would mean they likely attack in 3 to 5 more years if Putin is still in power, or if the next leader is militaristic.
 
How much money should we spend on a foreign war that doesn't involve us? Is there a limit? In my opinion, we should stop sending them support, we have spent enough.
You would prefer to spend more over the next 10 years globally to keep Russia in check? Not giving a larger blow to them now means all of NATO's commitments, including our own, need aggressively funded still. There is no net gain abiding by your opinion. You are however entitled to it, as you are to stretching what you might currently be comfortable with to achieve more lasting goals for all countries outside of Russia.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fsu1jreed
I love threads like this.

OP creates thread confidently
OP immediately gets made fun of because he can't read or got tricked by fake news
OP never acknowledges that he ****ed up despite people constantly asking him about his stupidity
......and 7 pages later people continue making fun of him


Just another reason why this site rules.
 
from what i’ve gathered russia has seized all the territory it wanted to seize — someone correct me if i’m wrong but all of the seized territory has overwhelmingly russian language majority. if russia tries for more they’ll be beset with internal strife and insurgency from ukranians which will be the worst outcome possible for them. so a ceasefire on paper should be a long lasting one if achieved
It’s not same language, it’s more cultural. I have Russian friends from the Russian side and they identify more with Ukraine.

That area is heavily Jewish on both sides. That’s a factor.
 
They'll quickly set their sights back to Gaza and those poor Palestinians.

And if that's going well they'll draw our attention to some outlier illegal immigrant mom and how they are being treated before being sent back.

And when the market rebounds they'll bitch about income inequality and housing prices and worker rights!

And when gas prices are low and inflation has haulted they'll complain about the environment and lack of green energy.

And they'll march, and they'll kick, and they'll scream, and they'll bitch about anything and everything because that's what they've always done.

They're a cancer.
Have you considered a career in clear, concise writing education??....Bravo post!!
 
A true American disgrace. Reagan would have dealt with Putin at the snap of his fingers. Arnold, Although he could never be president, would have sent Putin back to his cave.

Bob Dole, John McCain would have had him corralled in a NY minute b
 
A true American disgrace. Teagan would have dealt with Putin at the snap of his fingers. Arnold, Althea could never be president, would have sent Putin back to his cave.
We have spent trillions on defense so no country on the planet isn't within our military and economic influence. It boggles my mind people want to throw that investment away as useless over a couple hundred million and us refreshing our surplus stocks that do expire eventually. We have a chance to destroy Russia economically while leaving them without their Soviet stockpiles from the last time. They've purged many of their scientific community they relyed on for new weapons development in favor of corruption at every level and branch. You seem like a good egg, and thanks for your contributions to threads, especially as of late.
 
We have spent trillions on defense so no country on the planet isn't within our military and economic influence. It boggles my mind people want to throw that investment away as useless over a couple hundred million and us refreshing our surplus stocks that do expire eventually. We have a chance to destroy Russia economically while leaving them without their Soviet stockpiles from the last time. They've purged many of their scientific community they relyed on for new weapons development in favor of corruption at every level and branch. You seem like a good egg, and thanks for your contributions to threads, especially as of late.
We are able to unload our old stuff, get new stuff tested, and no loss of Americans lives.

Exportation of weapons, old and new is our biggest foreign income.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fsu1jreed
How's the ceasefire going? Has it started yet? Just wanted some updates since Putin agreed to it last week. Thanks!
Well considering the conditions for peace were “surrender or die” I’m pretty sure it will be a minute before we see any progress.

Trump’s Nobel prize will just have to wait until his boss has extracted the requisite pounds of flesh from Ukrainian women and children.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MitchLL
You would prefer to spend more over the next 10 years globally to keep Russia in check? Not giving a larger blow to them now means all of NATO's commitments, including our own, need aggressively funded still. There is no net gain abiding by your opinion. You are however entitled to it, as you are to stretching what you might currently be comfortable with to achieve more lasting goals for all countries outside of Russia.
yes, how do you not see that as a win for nato. Nato will out survive russia. The loss of this many military aged men will already hurt them in coming generations.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bcherod
yes, how do you not see that as a win for nato. Nato will out survive russia. The loss of this many military aged men will already hurt them in coming generations.
The post I responded to has context. The US trying to claim it is in the financial best interests of itself due to immediate budget savings, to let Russia keep gains and rest/rearm until they break a ceasefire, is ridiculously foolish. The US bought time for Ukraine to develop tech the west wouldn't part with, or didn't have, that are force multipliers. Ukraine is fighting Russia's wartime finances and military supply strains in a more creative way than any speculated.
 
You would prefer to spend more over the next 10 years globally to keep Russia in check? Not giving a larger blow to them now means all of NATO's commitments, including our own, need aggressively funded still. There is no net gain abiding by your opinion. You are however entitled to it, as you are to stretching what you might currently be comfortable with to achieve more lasting goals for all countries outside of Russia.
Russia can't take over Ukraine, and now they are going to take over the world? They have been in a stalemate for how long? We need to quit wasting our money on this. We have our own problems that we need to deal with.
 
Just checking in on this Russia agreement to a cease fire, hows it going?
It ain't. Putin has got lapdog Bonespurs over a barrel and Bonespurs still begging to be set free. His master has not yet decided. Needs more begging and groveling.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bcherod
Russia can't take over Ukraine, and now they are going to take over the world? They have been in a stalemate for how long? We need to quit wasting our money on this. We have our own problems that we need to deal with.
You might have your own problems to deal with.

I prefer to utilize the strengths of the US to ensure the world doesn't deteriorate around it. Which allowing Russia to without penalty invade it's border nations who used to be siblings in the USSR would be deterioration. I'm fine Europe lead the charge integrating Ukraine into the western economies post Russia gone.

Destabilizing the US position as a nation of trust does us no benefits. Do so and you will be whining why the dollar is no longer the default currency of the world. Trade wars when other currency is available to influence our currency is not smart.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT