ADVERTISEMENT

oppenheimer

bad, great or somewhere in between?


  • Total voters
    73
This is a 5, but it is not a perfect 5.

There's a lot of Nolan self-indulgent sh** in the movie, and while we all like boobies (well, most of us.....), at least one of the nude scenes was just gratuitous for the sake of it, and virtually unnecessary, and really just out of place in the context of the scene it took place in.

For example, in the opening scene of Saving Private Ryan, you're seeing the horrors of war, and Tom Hanks sees a guy on fire and then the camera cuts as the tank explodes, and then say he looks to his left and sees two people having sex on the beach......it was that jarring in the context of the scene.

Other than that and Hans Zimmer falling in love lately with taking lots of droning noises and calling it a movie score in his movies lately, including Dune.............it was a 5.

Fwiw, here's how I rank it:

3. Oppenheimer
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
2. Dune part 2
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
1. Shogun
Beach sex during Saving Private Ryan crippled me
 
I have for years thought what terrible thing to be responsible for creating something so evil and yet, easily justified when you know that the germans were working on one.
 
Barbie was a much better cinematic experience. Kudos to the Oppenhiemer marketing team to latching on to "Barbenhiemer" and riding that coattail, bc Barbie really carried the two.
I enjoyed both for different reasons - admittedly did not see Barbie (seeing it as a single with a room full of girls would have been weird) in theatre.

Both were excellent movies imo.
 
OVERRATED

I LOVE WWII era movies and really any movies that are historically based. This movie was decent, but I fell asleep MULTIPLE times while watching this snoozefest. It's good, but not deserving of all the praise.

Zero motivation to ever watch again.
 
OVERRATED

I LOVE WWII era movies and really any movies that are historically based. This movie was decent, but I fell asleep MULTIPLE times while watching this snoozefest. It's good, but not deserving of all the praise.

Zero motivation to ever watch again.
Were you startled awake by all the excessively loud background noise/music/"train-sound" spamming at any point?.................
 
I think Imma pirate this on a Chromebook using my 4G hotspot connection and see if it holds up to the IMAX experience or if I pause during Florence Pugh scene to do uncensored search on video.bing.com
 
watching now. i'd give it 4 stars. i can't shake the feeling i'm watching david byrne of talking heads.

I rated it a 5 and I have studied a lot of physics and science so I am into this type of stuff.

A fair number of posts on this thread thought the movie was too long or they didnt like it. Well the A bomb project was a Moon Shot type of project. It was of utmost importance and a super huge accomplishment of humans in a few short years. You cant tell this story in 2 hours.

And actually the PBS and British version in the 1980's starring Sam Waterson on Masterpiece was 6 or 7 episodes of an hour or more each. It went into the science somewhat deeper than this movie and also into the lives of the people. It was an excellent series and I highly recommend it to those who are interested in this man and the topic.
 
I rated it a 5 and I have studied a lot of physics and science so I am into this type of stuff.

A fair number of posts on this thread thought the movie was too long or they didnt like it. Well the A bomb project was a Moon Shot type of project. It was of utmost importance and a super huge accomplishment of humans in a few short years. You cant tell this story in 2 hours.

And actually the PBS and British version in the 1980's starring Sam Waterson on Masterpiece was 6 or 7 episodes of an hour or more each. It went into the science somewhat deeper than this movie and also into the lives of the people. It was an excellent series and I highly recommend it to those who are interested in this man and the topic.

Yep. Too big of a historical picture to knock out in 120 minutes
 
At age 77, I get bored easily when watching movies and a regular 1 1/2 to 2 hour film requires my breaking it down into about three segments. My attention span is completely shot to hell and three hours is daunting. To make matters worse, Oppenheimer is largely about government and the Federal Bureaucracy. This appeared to be a hopeless mission.

However, I watched Oppenheimer in one sitting. I could not stop watching.

It is a fabulous movie.
 
Last edited:
I liked Oppenheimer but doubt I'll ever watch it start to finish again. Off the top of my head, I thought Killers of the Flower Moon, Godzilla, Poor Things & Late Night w the Devil were all better.
Never saw Late Night, but the synopsis and previews made it look interesting.

KotFM is Oscar bait and therefore disqualified in my eyes, and Poor Things was Emma Stone porn nttawwt because I certainly didn't avert my eyes............

That leaves Godzilla Minus One as king of the movies in 2023. :cool:



People: "But what about Barb-"

 
At age 77, I get bored easily when watching movies and a regular 1 1/2 to 2 hour film requires my breaking it down into about three segments. My attention span is completely shot to hell and Three hours is daunting. To make matters worse, Oppenheimer is largely about government and the Federal Bureaucracy.

However, I watched Oppenheimer in one sitting. I could not stop watching.

It is a fabulous movie.

I couldn't think of starting and not finishing the movie. The story in itself is meaningful to my generation b/c we were raised with nuclear weapons testing and school emergency drills. Making Oppy human was interesting, and the ugliness of the McCarthy era style hearings is something these radical wing nuts on this board are so enamored with but have no idea the lives they destroyed. The same style hearings Jordan and other House members have tried, equally unsuccessful to function.
 
Never saw Late Night, but the synopsis and previews made it look interesting.

KotFM is Oscar bait and therefore disqualified in my eyes, and Poor Things was Emma Stone porn nttawwt because I certainly didn't avert my eyes............

That leaves Godzilla Minus One as king of the movies in 2023. :cool:



People: "But what about Barb-"

If you ever besmirch Marty like that again, I will outrun every Buford T Justice wannabe between here and Fort Dodge just to smack you. Shame on you. Marty is a saint
 
New mods just going to let Monkey libel Scorsese like that. Unreal what has happened to this place
giphy.gif
 
I gave it a 3. From all the awards, I thought it would be better. It was too long and really dragged at times. Too many characters and sometimes confusing as to who was who. Definitely worth seeing and good but I don’t think I would watch it again.
 
I was really looking forward to watching this but I have to say I was underwhelmed. Maybe my expectations were too high.

Came away thinking it was good but not something I'd rewatch which is my barometer for a movie. That and I watched it over the course of two nights.

Kind of like The English Patient in that regard...lot of hype, awards, but meh.
 
I was really looking forward to watching this but I have to say I was underwhelmed. Maybe my expectations were too high.

Came away thinking it was good but not something I'd rewatch which is my barometer for a movie. That and I watched it over the course of two nights.

Kind of like The English Patient in that regard...lot of hype, awards, but meh.
Watch it again.

But mute the background music.
 
  • Like
Reactions: binsfeldcyhawk2
I gave it a 3. From all the awards, I thought it would be better. It was too long and really dragged at times. Too many characters and sometimes confusing as to who was who. Definitely worth seeing and good but I don’t think I would watch it again.
I knew the story very well and the names of many of the scientists but once again Director Nolan used too loud of music and sound effects to make it so you couldnt hear the names of the people being introduced and some of the dialog.

To me that was the main drawback until I watched it online with closed captions.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT