Mox's mic popped me the hardest all night. We got two f-bombs and a JESUS CHRIST out of it. Go back and watch Bowens during the Acclaimed introduction, when he leans against the fans, nobody scissors him and I feel bad for him, lol.
The MJF/Bryan segment dragged on for me.
I enjoy what they're doing with Jade right now. Shida is obviously going to turn on Saraya and Toni and join Britt and Hayter so Saraya needs to call in a favor and POOF, newly signed Mercedes Mone is going to be their partner. Or Shida is going to take out Toni and they'll feud later, but Saraya still needs to get afka Sasha on her side.
Ricky Starks and Action Andretti could be the future, and I think Jericho knows that.
Really got the warm and fuzzies when Darby won, but good LORD they botched Wardlow, which is just true about anyone that they build up naturally. How do they do this EVERY time?! Daniel Garcia, Sammy Guevara (his own doing), 2.0 all cooled off by being aligned with Jericho. Shida, Thunder Rosa, Riho. Orange Cassidy, HOB they cooled off until Tommy End was like "no, I'm out" and now they're back but wtf are they even doing? There's a bunch more.
I prefer AEW but when they continuously botch people's arcs it makes it hard to invest. They feel like the Netflix of Wrestling right now. Get invested in a storyline just to have it cancelled after its best season without a conclusion (RIP 1899).
I agree with you in general, but I definitely don't agree that Jericho is a/the problem. In some ways, I think Jericho is the MVP of the promotion. He's given the rub to so many guys, either by aligning them into his stable, or feuding with them, or flat out jobbing to them. He's jobbed to Indy darlings like Orange Cassidy and Eddie Kingston to give them credibility, and massively elevated guys like Garcia and Guevara. He's frequently kept 8-10 or more members of the roster occupied in meaningful angles for months at a time. All without having to have himself in the world title picture. I think he's been invaluable in terms of just giving tons of guys something to do that people can follow, and usually care at least somewhat about. Without Jericho's angles, you'd have even more people with nothing to do.
That said, they do have problems with the storytelling, I totally agree. I wonder if it's the indy influence on the roster, which maybe isn't as well versed in long term weekly or biweekly television storytelling, and is more accustomed to "what do we need to do to get to and vaguely justify the next 5 star match?"
Another problem, I think, is frankly AEW's "smart" fan base, and having to cater to them. It's incredibly difficult to get the crowd turned on anyone who can actually work, which is the majority of the roster. So the vast majority of the roster are some kind of tweeners. I mean, MJF is a A+++ heel, and you still had the crowd cheering him and against Moxley at Full Gear.
Jericho can heel when he's a heel, and Christian (whose addition I was massively dubious about) has been a lifesaver as a heel. Stokley and Ethan Page do pretty well, I'd be pushing Ethan Page to the moon simply because he's willing to be an actual heel.
But how the hell do you keep momentum up on wrestlers' arcs when almost everyone is a good guy, or kind of a good guy. I said it before, Hangman's title was the culmination of the best storytelling they ever did, and then his reign was totally ruined by booking his title defenses against super popular quasi-babyfaces.
Wrestlers like Adam Cole, Penta, Pac, Britt Baker, House of Black, Eddie Kingston, the Bucks, etc etc are constantly booked into heel angles while being incredibly over and pretty much refusing to play the heel. To me that really hurts storytelling quite a bit.
And frankly, some of it is on the wrestler's themselves, some of them just can't carry an angle on their own. I think this is one area where AEW overcompensates maybe from Vince McMahon's reluctance to give in to smarts. Sometimes I think AEW gets out ahead of its skis on some of these fan-driven pushes. Wardlow is a great example, he had awesome momentum, a great program working with MJF who is a genius, and then what do you do with a guy who can't or doesn't have anything to say, has a limited ring repertoire, and his entire gimmick is "being a beast." Yeah, AEW should have done better not to squander what they had there, he really hadn't developed a character.
Same thing with Thunder Rosa, and I really like Thunder Rosa. She's a great worker, and has an awesome look, but she can't talk and doesn't have a defined personality, and once you got away from Britt Baker carrying the angle, there was nothing there. The in ring work is pretty strong across the board, but some of these wrestlers need more training on the outside the ring aspect before they get pushed, or think about pushing people that are second rate workers, but know how to make people give a shit, like Eddie Kingston.