The way I look at it, is that if he gets his act together and performs well in life and the classroom and AAs as a Hawkeye, Brands looks like a fantastic coach, it's a great story and turns out great for future recruiting. If he does what everyone predicts and f*cks up either in school or in his personal life, then he's at Iowa for only a couple of months, then out of the program and we move on, nothing lost.
Minimal downside with big upside. He's not going to become a cancer or destroy the culture of our program in 3 months, and Tom and Terry would never let it get to that point to begin with.
I think this is a poor decision and an unnecessary risk by our staff. Still, I hope it works out for us and for Downey. But I don't think it is this simple -- "if it works great, if not we cut the strings". Someone else mentioned it before, other coaches will use this to recruit against us. Spencer already mentioned that he experienced negative recruiting. This only provides more ammunition.