I'm going to throw this out there, and I'm sure some will disagree. We may find out if Jan really is "the post whisperer" or if she just came across some outstanding talent. Gus was a crazy talent, and she played with a great point guard to set her up. Then you had Monica who played all of her great three years with the best facilitator whos ever played in the womens game. She NEVER had to dribble BECAUSE CC22 always got her the ball at just the right time, and in exactly the right place. Last year we had Goodman, AOG, and AJE. Three post players in their third and 4th seasons. All had multiple seasons under Jans tutelage, and NONE of them played consistently enough to solidify that 5 spot, even with the benefit of playing with Clark. Bluder was still bemoaning their inconsistent play heading into the tournament. Did Jan suddenly forget how to coach these gals, or was there just not enough talent to work with? This seems to me to be alot like Kirk being an OL guru, and then we have multiple years with misses recruiting tackles specifically, and the OL looks poor. Did Kirk forget how to coach the OL?
So in the next couple of years Jan and Randi Peterson have Heiden and Hays to mold. The two highest ranked post players ever recruited to play for the Iowa women. You would think we'd see some all B1G, maybe even AA type results from those two over the next three years. What say you?
I don’t have a problem with your theorizing, but Jan didn’t name herself that. I’m assuming Lisa or some other coach’s did over her 25 year career @ Iowa. And I don’t think it just started with Meg. And although I loved Megan, you could definitely see her limitations when she turned pro, so I’m not sure how great she was. She clearly had some fantastic coaching.
I also think they are in transition about what Jan wants from her post. Meg and Monica were classic get to the block, dump in the ball and post pivot.
It’s funny really, and you’re a good fan and a smart one at that so I’m definitely not jerking your chain, but it comes back to my pet peeve. We have fans that think we suddenly changed to a “post first“ offense. When in reality, we are still running the same offense, Lisa Bluder did and I think Jan would like to add more motion and ultimately become even more fluid. CC made it look like we had a super explosive offense. Give Lisa some credit because clearly she saw Caitlns talent and encouraged them to get up and down the floor. But my point is this, I belive Ava is the future of the program, @ the 5, but she is not a dump it inside, post pivot player. Yet at least…
I honestly think she’s more a face the basket kind of five. I’m not trying to get in another pissing match with anyone else before this game starts but the reality is Ava is fairly athletic, but she’s not super fluid yet, shes young, in fact she looks extremely young, she does not have a great lower base, she can get pushed around and she’s a fouling machine.
Yes, it would be super nice to just experiment all season long with the big tall freshman but at some point in time you gotta figure out what it takes to win basketball games and it’s really odd to me how much fanfare this girl has gotten. And honestly, I don’t think she’s gonna leave, I believe she likes it here but if she does, it is what it is.
And listen, I get the mindset. You’re probably a lot like me in that you like to think things through, hypothesis, theorize, project & maybe even sometimes play devils advocate. But my rule of thumb is “can I see it”… for example, a play call or a pass attempt, run attempt, defensive philosophy, FG attempt, Shot attempt, etc. etc. that might seem dumb on the surface, but if I can at least comprehend where it was coming from, I can understand and accept, even if I don’t agree per se.
But for me, there are just a bunch of people that go “oh wow Ava is a top 40 recruit” she’s clearly really good. The coach's clearly don’t know what they’re doing.
And for me I have not seen one single thing that made me say holy shit is Ava really good. I’ve seen things that made me say wow she’s got a real shot to be pretty solid, but I can more easily see why she’s not playing consistently.